Skip to content

Manuscripts

Check a draft against the papers it cites, compare versions, audit the reference list, and export a citation report.

On this page

Manuscripts checks a draft you are writing against the papers it cites. Every cited sentence is held against the paper's own text, and you see which sentences hold, which do not, and why, quoted from the paper. It lives under Research, in your own account or in a team's.

Start a draft

Open Research > Manuscripts and choose New draft. Upload a .docx, .md, .tex, .bib or .txt file, or paste the text. Number your citations, such as [1], or use author and year, and keep the reference list at the end under a heading such as References.

The check reads each reference, finds the paper, and grades every sentence that cites it:

Verdict What it means
Supports The paper says it.
Partly The paper supports part of the sentence.
Does not support The paper does not say it.
Contradicts The paper says otherwise, often a figure that differs.
Wrong paper The identifier leads to a different work than the one you named.
Not found No index has the reference. Check it.
Paper has a notice The paper was retracted, withdrawn, corrected or put under concern.
Needs the PDF No open copy was found. Add the PDF and the sentence is checked against the full text.

A PDF you add is read in your browser. The file is kept with the draft, where only the people who can open the draft can read it, and it is deleted with the draft.

Write and cite

The draft is an editor: write in it, and each sentence you leave is checked again against the paper it cites. Type [ where a citation goes and a list opens under the caret:

  • [8 cites entry 8 of your list. [3,5 and [2-4 cite several at once, and [3, p. 12 adds the page. A [ typed right after a citation adds to it, so [1] becomes [1, 2].
  • Words after the bracket search for papers. A DOI, an arXiv id, a PubMed id or a link to any of them names that paper alone.
  • If you linked your Zotero library under Connections, your own papers are listed before the ones found elsewhere. Zotero is read by your browser with your read-only key, never by naulon.

You can also cite a paper's own words. Open a paper in Sources and press Cite with this passage under a passage, or select words in its abstract or a passage and press Cite with the selected words. The citation keeps those words, shown with a dotted underline, and the check grades your sentence against them instead of the paper's best match. When the paper's text naulon reads does not hold them, the sentence's card says so and the whole paper is read instead.

Sources, beside the draft, has three views. In this draft lists your references. Find searches the papers naulon holds and OpenAlex, Crossref, Europe PMC (with PubMed), arXiv, Semantic Scholar, DOAJ and OpenAIRE at once, ranks them by how close each is to your sentence, and opens any paper on the passages that match it, so you can read before you cite. Saved is a reading list everyone on the draft shares, up to 200 papers. Import a .bib or RIS file there to bring your existing library: a paper with a DOI, arXiv id or PubMed id is saved, and one without is left out and counted. A saved paper that was retracted or withdrawn says so on its row. Searching and reading are free.

Right-click and spelling

Right-click anywhere in the draft for what you can do there: spellings for a word marked as misspelled, the paper behind a citation, the check on a graded sentence, accepting or rejecting a suggestion, citing at that point, and cut, copy and paste. Shift+F10 or the menu key opens it at the cursor. Shift+right-click gives you your browser's own menu instead.

Misspelled words get a thin red wave. Spelling runs in your browser, so your text is not sent anywhere to be spelled. It knows English (US and UK), German, Spanish and French, and picks the language from what the draft is written in; change it from the last row of the menu. Words research papers use that general dictionaries leave out (methylation, convolutional, immunohistochemistry) are accepted, and so are the names and titles in your reference list.

A word it still marks can go in one of two places:

  • Your dictionary: accepted on every draft you write. Only you see it. Up to 2,000 words.
  • This draft's words: accepted for everyone on the draft, which suits a gene, a drug or a method your co-authors all use. Anyone who can comment can add one; an editor can take out any, a commenter only their own. Up to 500 words.

Spelling dictionary, in the menu or under Actions, lists both and lets you find, add and take out words. Japanese drafts are not spelled.

Versions and comparing them

Each revision is a new version, checked as its own build. The head says what changed since the version before, such as "2 fixed, 1 new since v1". To compare any two, open Versions from the version chip in the head and choose Compare on an older one. You get every sentence that newly fails, every sentence still open (with its old and new verdict when it moved), and every sentence fixed, either because it now holds or because it is no longer in the draft as written.

The reference list

The References pane reads the list as a whole:

  • Cited, with no entry: an in-text citation such as [14] or (Smith, 2020) that names no entry in the list.
  • Listed, never cited: an entry no sentence cites.
  • Listed twice: the same work in the list more than once.
  • Age: the newest year, the median, and how many references are more than ten years old.
  • What the draft leans on: for each reference, how many sentences cite it and how many cite nothing else. If one of those papers were retracted, those sentences would lose their only source. A paper that already has a notice and carries sentences alone is marked.

The evidence map, which draws each sentence to the paper it cites, opens from the same pane.

The assistant

The Assistant pane runs a plan you see before it starts: check every citation, fix references that broke, find support for sentences that do not hold, or referee the sentences that do by looking for passages that argue against them. You can also ask in your own words. Every sentence's card offers the one step its verdict calls for, with its cost: a sentence that holds is refereed, a wrong or missing reference is fixed, and a sentence that does not hold gets a source found. The assistant works on the draft as it is now. What it finds comes back as proposals, and Accept into the draft changes the text everyone on the draft sees. Grades always come from naulon's judge, even when your own model key plans the work.

Problems also lists the sentences that state a finding and cite nothing. Pick one and the caret goes where its citation belongs.

A run on your own key shows what it used: the model, the tokens in and out, and the cost. The cost is your vendor's own figure when its reply includes one, the list price when we have it, and "price not known" otherwise. Model keys, under Connections, adds up the month so far from the 1st (UTC). Grades never run on your key, so they are not in either.

Working with others

Share a draft by email as a viewer, commenter or editor. Anyone who can comment can start a thread on a sentence and assign it. A thread stays with its sentence into the next version as long as the sentence and its reference read the same. A team's drafts are open to everyone in the team who may read drafts.

Turn on Suggesting in the draft's head (Ctrl+Alt+Shift+X, or Cmd+Option+Shift+X on a Mac) and your edits become suggestions instead of text: new words are underlined in your colour, removed words are struck through, and nothing changes until someone accepts. An editor who suggests can also change a heading's level, an equation or a footnote, and each shows as a suggestion. A commenter always writes this way, and suggests words, paragraph breaks, citations, and new equations and footnotes; changing an existing heading, equation, footnote or figure is left to an editor. Put the caret in a suggestion to see who made it, when, and what it does, with Accept and Reject for an editor and Withdraw for the person who made it; Alt+F10 moves to those buttons from the keyboard. The status line counts the open suggestions and lists them, with Accept all and Reject all. Undo puts back a decision you made in the editor. The check reads the draft as written until a suggestion is accepted, a saved version keeps the text without open suggestions, and a card warns when a suggestion would take a citation out.

A commenter can also suggest a rewrite of a sentence through the assistant. naulon's judge grades it against the paper the sentence cites before anyone can insert it, for 1 credit from the draft owner's research credits, and the suggestion appears in the sentence's thread with its grade. Only an editor can accept it, and only a rewrite graded as supported can go into the draft. An accepted change says which version it went into and links to it. When an editor dismisses a proposal with a reason, the reason is posted to the sentence's thread, so everyone on it sees why.

Watch a draft to hear, by email and in the bell, when a paper it cites is retracted, withdrawn, corrected or put under concern.

Export

This draft goes out as you see it now, in the citation style you pick: as written, APA 7, Chicago (author-date), Harvard, Vancouver, IEEE or Nature. Each reference naulon found is written from the paper's record (authors, year, title, journal and DOI), and one it did not find keeps your words. As a Word file, equations are Word's own built-up math. As LaTeX you get a folder with the .tex and a references.bib, so BibTeX sets the list in the chosen style or in whatever style your journal's template names. PDF prints from your browser. When the draft holds suggestions nobody has decided, choose whether to leave them out, take them all, or, in a Word file, keep them as tracked changes that Word's Review shows under each author's name.

For a finished version, Export also offers:

  • Comments in your file: pick the file you checked again and get a copy with one comment on every cited sentence. The file is read and written in your browser.
  • The evidence lockfile: every sentence pinned to the passage, the text version and the grade it stood on. You can publish it at a public verify address so an editor can check each finding.
  • Comments for a peer review: numbered comments in manuscript order, each with the sentence, the reference, the verdict, the figures as written and as reported, and the paper's own words. Paste them into a review form. No model writes any of it.
  • The citation report: one page for a submission or a supervisor with what holds, what needs attention, the reference list, the papers with notices and the lockfile's fingerprint. Print it or save it as a PDF.
  • The AI-use statement journals ask for, written from the rewrites you accepted.

From Claude or ChatGPT

Connect your naulon account to an AI app (how) and it can read your drafts as they are now, with each sentence's verdict and the paper's own words, find and read papers for a sentence, and compare two versions. If you let it write when you connect, it can also comment on a sentence, save a paper to the reading list, accept or dismiss a suggestion, suggest an edit as a tracked change in your name, and, on a draft you edit, accept or reject tracked changes. Spending research credits on a check or the assistant is a separate switch, per app, in Connected apps. An agent checking a text it wrote itself can call the free naulon_check_answer tool, which also reads the reference list whole.

Credits

Checks and assistant runs use research credits. See Billing for what a credit is, how many each plan includes, and how to add more.