Phenotypic landscape inference reveals multiple evolutionary paths to C4 photosynthesis

Abstract

C4 photosynthesis has independently evolved from the ancestral C3 pathway in at least 60 plant lineages, but, as with other complex traits, how it evolved is unclear. Here we show that the polyphyletic appearance of C4 photosynthesis is associated with diverse and flexible evolutionary paths that group into four major trajectories. We conducted a meta-analysis of 18 lineages containing species that use C3, C4, or intermediate C3–C4 forms of photosynthesis to parameterise a 16-dimensional phenotypic landscape. We then developed and experimentally verified a novel Bayesian approach based on a hidden Markov model that predicts how the C4 phenotype evolved. The alternative evolutionary histories underlying the appearance of C4 photosynthesis were determined by ancestral lineage and initial phenotypic alterations unrelated to photosynthesis. We conclude that the order of C4 trait acquisition is flexible and driven by non-photosynthetic drivers. This flexibility will have facilitated the convergent evolution of this complex trait.

Full text

Its licence does not allow us to show the full text. Read it at PubMed Central:

References 89

1. 1.

   Abramoff MD Magalhaes PJ Ram SJ 2004 Image processing with ImageJ. Biophotonics Int11:36–42

   Not in our library

2. 2.

   Adams CA Leung F Sun SSM 1986 Molecular properties of phosphoenolpyruvate carboxylase from C3, C3-C4 intermediate, and C4 Flaveria species. Planta167:218–25.

   Not in our library10.1007/bf00391418

3. 3.

   Akyildiz M Gowik U Engelmann S Koczor M Streubel M Westhoff P 2007 Evolution and function of a cis-regulatory module for mesophyll-specific gene expression in the C4 dicot Flaveria trinervia. Plant Cell19:3391–402.

   Not in our library10.1105/tpc.107.053322

4. 4.

   Aubry S Brown NJ Hibberd JM 2011 The role of proteins in C3 plants prior to their recruitment into the C4 pathway. J Exp Bot62:3049–59.

   Not in our library10.1093/jxb/err012

5. 5.

   Beebe DU Evert RF 1990 The morphology and anatomy of the leaf of Moricandia arvensis (L.) DC. (Brassicaceae). Bot Gaz151:184–203.

   Not in our library10.1086/337818

6. 6.

   Brown NJ Newell CA Stanley S Chen JE Perrin AJ Kajala K 2011 Independent and parallel recruitment of preexisting mechanisms underlying C4 photosynthesis. Science331:1436–9.

   Not in our library10.1126/science.1201248

7. 7.

   Brown RH Hattersley PW 1989 Leaf anatomy of C3-C4 species as related to evolution of C4 photosynthesis. Plant Physiol91:1543–50.

   Not in our library10.1104/pp.91.4.1543

8. 8.

   Bruhl JJ Perry S 1995 Photosynthetic pathway-related ultrastructure of C3, C4 and C3-like C3-C4 intermediate sedges (Cyperaceae), with special reference to Eleocharis. Aust J Plant Physiol22:521.

   Not in our library10.1071/pp9950521

9. 9.

   Bustin SA 2000 Absolute quantification of mRNA using real-time reverse transcription polymerase chain reaction assays. J Mol Endocrinol25:169–93.

   Not in our library10.1677/jme.0.0250169

10. 10.

    Casati P Fresco AG Andreo CS Drincovich MF 1999 An intermediate form of NADP-malic enzyme from the C3-C4 intermediate species Flaveria floridana. Plant Science147:101–9.

    Not in our library10.1016/s0168-9452(99)00101-6

11. 11.

    Cheng SH Moore BD Edwards GE Ku MS 1988 Photosynthesis in Flaveria brownii, a C4-like species: leaf anatomy, characteristics of CO2 exchange, compartmentation of photosynthetic enzymes, and metabolism of CO2. Plant Physiol87:867–73.

    Not in our library10.1104/pp.87.4.867

12. 12.

    Christin P-A Osborne CP Chatelet DS Columbus JT Besnard G Hodkinson TR 2013 Anatomical enablers and the evolution of C4 photosynthesis in grasses. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA110:1381–6.

    Not in our library10.1073/pnas.1216777110

13. 13.

    Christin P-A Osborne CP Sage RF Arakaki M Edwards EJ 2011b C4 eudicots are not younger than C4 monocots. J Exp Bot62:3171–81.

    Not in our library10.1093/jxb/err041

14. 14.

    Christin P-A Sage TL Edwards EJ Ogburn RM Khoshravesh R Sage RF 2011a Complex evolutionary transitions and the significance of C3-C4 intermediate forms of photosynthesis in Molluginaceae. Evolution65:643–60.

    Not in our library10.1111/j.1558-5646.2010.01168.x

15. 15.

    Christin P Besnard G Samaritani E Duvall M Hodkinson T Savolainen V 2008 Oligocene CO2 decline promoted C4 photosynthesis in grasses. Curr Biol18:37–43.

    Not in our library10.1016/j.cub.2007.11.058

16. 16.

    Christin P Salamin N Savolainen V Duvall M Besnard G 2007 C4 photosynthesis evolved in grasses via parallel adaptive genetic changes. Curr Biol17:1241–7.

    Not in our library10.1016/j.cub.2007.06.036

17. 17.

    Devi MT Raghavendra AS 1993 Partial reduction in activities of photorespiratory enzymes in C3-C4 intermediates of Alternanthera and Parthenium. J Exp Bot44:779–84.

    Not in our library10.1093/jxb/44.4.779

18. 18.

    Devi MT Rajagopalan AV Raghavendra AS 1995 Predominant localization of mitochondria enriched with glycine-decarboxylating enzymes in bundle sheath cells of Alternanthera tenella, a C3-C4 intermediate species. Plant Cell Environ18:589–94.

    Not in our library10.1111/j.1365-3040.1995.tb00559.x

19. 19.

    Edwards EJ Osborne CP Stromberg CAE Smith SA C4 grasses consortium 2010 The origins of C4 grasslands: integrating evolutionary and ecosystem science. Science328:587–91.

    Not in our library10.1126/science.1177216

20. 20.

    Furbank RT 2011 Evolution of the C4 photosynthetic mechanism: are there really three C4 acid decarboxylation types?J Exp Bot62:3103–8.

    Not in our library10.1093/jxb/err080

21. 21.

    Gavrilets S 1997 Evolution and speciation on holey adaptive landscapes. Trends Ecol Evol12:307–12.

    Not in our library10.1016/s0169-5347(97)01098-7

22. 22.

    Goldstein L Ray T Kestler D Mayne B Brown R Black C 1976 Biochemical characterization of panicum species which are intermediate between C3 and C4 photosynthesis plants. Plant Sci6:85–90.

    Not in our library10.1016/0304-4211(76)90140-1

23. 23.

    Gowik U Brautigam A Weber KL Weber APM Westhoff P 2011 Evolution of C4 photosynthesis in the genus Flaveria: how many and which genes does it take to make C4?Plant Cell23:2087–105.

    Not in our library10.1105/tpc.111.086264

24. 24.

    Griffiths H Weller G Toy LFM Dennis RJ 2013 You’re so vein: bundle sheath physiology, phylogeny and evolution in C3 and C4 plants. Plant Cell Environ36:249–61.

    Not in our library10.1111/j.1365-3040.2012.02585.x

25. 25.

    Hatch MD Kagawa T Craig S 1975 Subdivision of C4 pathway species based on differing C4 acid decarboxylating systems and ultrastructural features. Aust J Plant Physiol2:111–28.

    Not in our library10.1071/pp9750111

26. 26.

    Hattersley PW 1984 Characterization of C4 type leaf anatomy in grasses (Poaceae). Mesophyll: bundle sheath area ratios. Ann Bot53:163–80

    Not in our library

27. 27.

    Hattersley PW Stone NE 1986 Photosynthetic enzyme activities in the C3-C4 intermediate Neurachne minor. Aust J Plant Physiol13:399.

    Not in our library10.1071/pp9860399

28. 28.

    Heckman D Schulze S Denton A Gowik U Westhoff P Weber APM 2013 Predicting C4 photosynthesis evolution: modular, individually adaptive steps on a Mount Fuji fitness landscape. Cell153:1579–88.

    Not in our library10.1016/j.cell.2013.04.058

29. 29.

    Hibberd JM Sheehy JE Langdale JA 2008 Using C4 photosynthesis to increase the yield of rice-rationale and feasibility. Curr Opin Plant Biol11:228–31.

    Not in our library10.1016/j.pbi.2007.11.002

30. 30.

    Hill RC Egydio de Carvalho C Salogiannis J Schlager B Pilgrim D Haag ES 2006 Genetic flexibility in the convergent evolution of hermaphroditism in Caenorhabditis nematodes. Dev Cell10:531–8.

    Not in our library10.1016/j.devcel.2006.02.002

31. 31.

    Holaday AS Black CC 1981 Comparative characterization of phosphoenolpyruvate carboxylase in C3, C4, and C3-C4 intermediate Panicum species. Plant Physiol67:330–4.

    Not in our library10.1104/pp.67.2.330

32. 32.

    Holaday AS Lee KW Chollet R 1984 C3-C4 Intermediate species in the genus Flaveria: leaf anatomy, ultrastructure, and the effect of O2 on the CO2 compensation concentration. Planta160:25–32.

    Not in our library10.1007/bf00392462

33. 33.

    Holaday AS Shieh Y-J Lee KW Chollet R 1981 Anatomical, ultrastructural and enzymic studies of leaves of Moricandia arvensis, a C3-C4 intermediate species. Biochim Biophys Acta637:334–41.

    Not in our library10.1016/0005-2728(81)90172-9

34. 34.

    Hylton CM Rawsthorne S Smith AM Jones DA Woolhouse HW 1988 Glycine decarboxylase is confined to the bundle-sheath cells of leaves of C3-C4 intermediate species. Planta175:452–9.

    Not in our library10.1007/bf00393064

35. 35.
    Evaluating Methods for Isolating Total RNA and Predicting the Success of Sequencing Phylogenetically Diverse Plant Transcriptomes · 2012

    No notice
36. 36.

    Kajala K Brown NJ Williams BP Borrill P Taylor LE Hibberd JM 2012 Multiple Arabidopsis genes primed for recruitment into C4 photosynthesis. Plant J69:47–56.

    Not in our library10.1111/j.1365-313x.2011.04769.x

37. 37.

    Keeley JE 1999 Photosynthetic pathway diversity in a seasonal pool community. Funct Ecol13:106–18.

    Not in our library10.1046/j.1365-2435.1999.00294.x

38. 38.

    Kennedy RA Eastburn JL Jensen KG 1980 C3-C4 Photosynthesis in the genus Mollugo: structure, physiology and evolution of intermediate characteristics. Am J Bot67:1207–17.

    Not in our library10.2307/2442363

39. 39.

    Khoshravesh R Hossein A Sage TL Nordenstam B Sage RF 2012 Phylogeny and photosynthetic pathway distribution in Anticharis Endl. (Scrophulariaceae). J Exp Bot63:5645–58.

    Not in our library10.1093/jxb/ers218

40. 40.

    Kidwell SM Holland SM 2002 The quality of the fossil record: implications for evolutionary analyses. Ann Rev Ecol Syst33:561–88.

    Not in our library10.1146/annurev.ecolsys.33.030602.152151

41. 41.

    Koteyeva NK Voznesenskaya EV Roalson EH Edwards GE 2010 Diversity in forms of C4 in the genus Cleome (Cleomaceae). Ann Bot107:269–83.

    Not in our library10.1093/aob/mcq239

42. 42.

    Kozmik Z Ruzickova J Jonasova K Matsumoto Y Vopalensky P Kozmikova I 2008 Assembly of the cnidarian camera-type eye from vertebrate-like components. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA105:8989–93.

    Not in our library10.1073/pnas.0800388105

43. 43.

    Ku MSB Edwards GE 1978 Photosynthetic efficiency of Panicum hians and Panicum milioides in relation to C3 and C4 plants. PlantCell Physiol19:665–75

    Not in our library

44. 44.

    Ku MSB Edwards GE Kanai R 1976 Distribution of enzymes related to C3 and C4 pathway of photosynthesis between mesophyll and bundle sheath cells of Panicum hians and Panicum milioides. Plant Cell Physiol17:615–20

    Not in our library

45. 45.

    Ku MSB Monson RK Littlejohn RO Nakamoto H Fisher DB Edwards GE 1983 Photosynthetic characteristics of C3-C4 intermediate Flaveria species1: I. leaf anatomy, photosynthetic responses to O2 and CO2, and activities of key enzymes in the C3 and C4 Pathways. Plant Physiol71:944–8.

    Not in our library10.1104/pp.71.4.944

46. 46.

    Ku MSB Wu J Dai Z Scott RA Chu C Edwards GE 1991 Photosynthetic and photorespiratory characteristics of Flaveria species. Plant Physiol96:518–28.

    Not in our library10.1104/pp.96.2.518

47. 47.

    Langdale JA 2011 C4 cycles: past, present, and future research on C4 photosynthesis. Plant Cell23:3879–92.

    Not in our library10.1105/tpc.111.092098

48. 48.

    Livak KJ Schmittgen TD 2001 Analysis of relative gene expression data using real-time quantitative PCR and the 2(-Delta DeltaC(T)) method. Methods25:402–8.

    Not in our library10.1006/meth.2001.1262

49. 49.

    Lobkovsky AE Wolf YI Koonin EV 2011 Predictability of evolutionary trajectories in fitness landscapes. PLOS Comput Biol7:e1002302.

    Not in our library10.1371/journal.pcbi.1002302

50. 50.

    McKown AD Dengler NG 2007 Key innovations in the evolution of Kranz anatomy and C4 vein pattern in Flaveria (Asteraceae). Am J Bot94:382–99.

    Not in our library10.3732/ajb.94.3.382

51. 51.

    McKown AD Moncalvo J-M Dengler NG 2005 Phylogeny of Flaveria (Asteraceae) and inference of C4 photosynthesis evolution. Am J Bot92:1911–28.

    Not in our library10.3732/ajb.92.11.1911

52. 52.

    Mooers AO Heard SB 2013 Inferring evolutionary process from phylogenetic tree shape. Q Rev Biol72:31–54.

    Not in our library10.1086/419657

53. 53.

    Moore BD Franceschi VR Cheng S-H Wu J Ku MSB 1987 Photosynthetic characteristics of the C3-C4 intermediate Parthenium hysterophorus. Plant Physiol85:978–83.

    Not in our library10.1104/pp.85.4.978

54. 54.

    Muhaidat R Sage TL Frohlich MW Dengler NG Sage RF 2011 Characterization of C3-C4 intermediate species in the genus Heliotropium L. (Boraginaceae): anatomy, ultrastructure and enzyme activity. Plant Cell Environ34:1723–36.

    Not in our library10.1111/j.1365-3040.2011.02367.x

55. 55.

    Osborne CP Sack L 2012 Evolution of C4 plants: a new hypothesis for an interaction of CO2 and water relations mediated by plant hydraulics. Philos Trans R Soc Lond B Biol Sci367:583–600.

    Not in our library10.1098/rstb.2011.0261

56. 56.

    P’yankov VI Voznesenskaya EV Kondratschuk AV Black CC 1997 A comparative anatomical and biochemical analysis in Salsola (Chenopodiaceae) species with and without a Kranz type leaf anatomy: a possible reversion of C4 to C3 photosynthesis. Am J Bot84:597

    Not in our library

57. 57.

    Rabiner L 1989 A tutorial on hidden Markov models and selected applications in speech recognition. Proc IEEE77:257–86.

    Not in our library10.1109/5.18626

58. 58.

    Rajendrudu G Prasad JSR Das VSR 1986 C3-C4 intermediate species in Alternanthera (Amaranthaceae)1: leaf anatomy, CO2 compensation point, net CO2 exchange and activities of photosynthetic enzymes. Plant Physiol80:409–14.

    Not in our library10.1104/pp.80.2.409

59. 59.

    Rathnam CKM Chollet R 1978 CO2 donation by malate and aspartate reduces photorespiration in Panicum milioides, A C3-C4 intermediate species. Biochem Biophys Res Comm85:801–8.

    Not in our library10.1016/0006-291x(78)91233-0

60. 60.

    Rathnam CKM Chollet R 1979 Photosynthetic carbon metabolism in Panicum milioides, a C3-C4 intermediate species: evidence for a limited C4 dicarboxylic acid pathway of photosynthesis. Biochim Biophys Acta548:500–19.

    Not in our library10.1016/0005-2728(79)90061-6

61. 61.

    Rawsthorne S Hylton CM Smith AM Woolhouse HW 1988 Photorespiratory metabolism and immunogold localization of photorespiratory enzymes in leaves of C3 and C3-C4 intermediate species of Moricandia. Planta173:298–308.

    Not in our library10.1007/bf00401016

62. 62.

    Rawsthorne S Morgan CL O’Neill CM Hylton CM Jones DA Frean ML 1998 Cellular expression pattern of the glycine decarboxylase P protein in leaves of an intergeneric hybrid between the C3-C4 intermediate species Moricandia nitens and the C3 species Brassica napus. Theoret App Genet96:922–7.

    Not in our library10.1007/s001220050821

63. 63.

    Revuz D Yor M 1999 Continuous Martingales and Brownian Motion. Springer

    Not in our library

64. 64.

    Rosche E Streubel M Westhoff P 1994 Primary structure of the photosynthetic pyruvate orthophosphate dikinase of the C3 plant Flaveria pringlei and expression analysis of pyruvate orthophosphate dikinase sequences in C3, C3-C4 and C4 Flaveria species. Plant Mol Biol26:763–9.

    Not in our library10.1007/bf00013761

65. 65.

    Roweis S 1998 Em algorithms for PCA and SPCA. Advances in Neural Information Processing Systems. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press p. 626–32

    Not in our library

66. 66.

    Sage RF Christin P-A Edwards EJ 2011a The C4 plant lineages of planet Earth. J Exp Bot62:3155–69.

    Not in our library10.1093/jxb/err048

67. 67.

    Sage RF Sage TL Kocacinar F 2012 Photorespiration and the evolution of C4 photosynthesis. Annu Rev Plant Biol63:19–47.

    Not in our library10.1146/annurev-arplant-042811-105511

68. 68.

    Sage TL Sage RF Vogan PJ Rahman B Johnson DC Oakley JC 2011b The occurrence of C2 photosynthesis in Euphorbia subgenus Chamaesyce (Euphorbiaceae). J Exp Bot62:3183–95.

    Not in our library10.1093/jxb/err059

69. 69.

    Santos JC Coloma LA Cannatella DC 2003 Multiple, recurring origins of aposematism and diet specialization in poison frogs. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA100:12792–7.

    Not in our library10.1073/pnas.2133521100

70. 70.

    Sayre RT Kennedy RA Pringnitz DJ 1979 Photosynthetic enzyme activities and localization in Mollugo verticillata populations differing in the levels of C3 and C4 cycle operation. Plant Physiol64:293–9.

    Not in our library10.1104/pp.64.2.293

71. 71.

    Slack CR Hatch MD 1967 Comparative studies on the activity of carboxylases and other enzymes in relation to the new pathway of photosynthetic carbon dioxide fixation in tropical grasses. Biochem J103:660–5.

    Not in our library10.1042/bj1030660

72. 72.

    Smith RD Brown B Ikonomi P Schechter AN 2003 Exogenous reference RNA for normalization of real-time quantitative PCR. BioTechniques34:88–91

    Not in our library10.2144/03341st05

73. 73.

    Steiner CC Römpler H Boettger LM Schöneberg T Hoekstra HE 2009 The genetic basis of phenotypic convergence in beach mice: similar pigment patterns but different genes. Mol Biol Evol26:35–45.

    Not in our library10.1093/molbev/msn218

74. 74.

    Ueno O Bang SW Wada Y Kondo A Ishihara K Kaneko Y 2003 Structural and biochemical dissection of photorespiration in hybrids differing in genome constitution between Diplotaxis tenuifolia (C3-C4) and Radish (C3). Plant Physiol132:1550–9.

    Not in our library10.1104/pp.103.021329

75. 75.

    Ueno O Wada Y Wakai M Bang SW 2006 Evidence from photosynthetic characteristics for the hybrid origin of Diplotaxis muralis from a C3-C4 intermediate and a C3 species. Plant Biol8:253–9.

    Not in our library10.1055/s-2005-873050

76. 76.

    Vicentini A Barber JC Aliscioni SS Giussani LM Kellogg EA 2008 The age of the grasses and clusters of origins of C4 photosynthesis. Glob Change Biol14:2963–77.

    Not in our library10.1111/j.1365-2486.2008.01688.x

77. 77.

    Vogan PJ Frohlich MW Sage RF 2007 The functional significance of C3-C4 intermediate traits in Heliotropium L. (Boraginaceae): gas exchange perspectives. Plant Cell Environ30:1337–45.

    Not in our library10.1111/j.1365-3040.2007.01706.x

78. 78.

    Voznesenskaya EV Artyusheva EG Franceschi VR Pyankov VI Kiirats O Ku M 2001 Salsola arbusculiformis, a C3-C4 Intermediate in Salsoleae (Chenopodiaceae). Ann Bot88:337–48.

    Not in our library10.1006/anbo.2001.1457

79. 79.

    Voznesenskaya EV Koteyeva NK Chuong SDX Ivanova AN Barroca J Craven LA 2007 Physiological, anatomical and biochemical characterisation of photosynthetic types in genus Cleome (Cleomaceae). Funct Plant Biol34:247.

    Not in our library10.1071/fp06287

80. 80.

    Voznesenskaya EV Koteyeva NK Edwards GE Ocampo G 2010 Revealing diversity in structural and biochemical forms of C4 photosynthesis and a C3-C4 intermediate in genus Portulaca L. (Portulacaceae). J Exp Bot61:3647–62.

    Not in our library10.1093/jxb/erq178

81. 81.

    Wasserman L 2004 All of statistics: a concise course in statistical inference. Springer

    Not in our library

82. 82.

    Weinreich DM Watson RA Chao L 2005 Sign epistasis and genetic constraint on evolutionary trajectories. Evolution59:1165–74.

    Not in our library10.1111/j.0014-3820.2005.tb01768.x

83. 83.

    Whibley AC Langlade NB Andalo C Hanna AI Bangham A Thébaud C 2006 Evolutionary paths underlying flower color variation in Antirrhinum. Science313:963–6.

    Not in our library10.1126/science.1129161

84. 84.

    Williams BP Aubry S Hibberd JM 2012 Molecular evolution of genes recruited into C4 photosynthesis. Trends Plant Sci17:213–20.

    Not in our library10.1016/j.tplants.2012.01.008

85. 85.

    Wilson JS Williams KA Forister ML von Dohlen CD Pitts JP 2012 Repeated evolution in overlapping mimicry rings among North American velvet ants. Nat Commun3:1272.

    Not in our library10.1038/ncomms2275

86. 86.

    Wiludda C Schulze S Gowik U Engelmann S Koczor M Streubel M 2012 Regulation of the photorespiratory GLDPA gene in C4 Flaveria: an intricate interplay of transcriptional and post-transcriptional processes. Plant Cell24:137–51.

    Not in our library10.1105/tpc.111.093872

87. 87.

    Wittkopp PJ Williams BL Selegue JE Carroll SB 2003 Drosophila pigmentation evolution: divergent genotypes underlying convergent phenotypes. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA100:1808–13.

    Not in our library10.1073/pnas.0336368100

88. 88.

    Wright S 1932 The roles of mutation, inbreeding, crossbreeding and selection in evolution. Proc Sixth Int Congr Genet1:356–66

    Not in our library

89. 89.

    Zhu X-G Long SP Ort DR 2008 What is the maximum efficiency with which photosynthesis can convert solar energy into biomass?Curr Opin Biotechnol19:153–9.

    Not in our library10.1016/j.copbio.2008.02.004

Cited by papers we hold 2

• Evolution of C4 photosynthesis predicted by constraint-based modelling · 2019
  Not checked
• The role of photorespiration during the evolution of C4 photosynthesis in the genus Flaveria · 2014
  No notice

Reads

A person counts once a day per paper. We keep no cookie and no address: a reader is a hash that changes every day. Any month under five reads shows no number.