Skip to content
naulon
Not checkedNot checked for notices yet.

A case to be made: theoretical and empirical arguments for the need to consider fatigue in post-stroke motor rehabilitation

Annette Sterr, Leonardo Furlan

Neural Regeneration Research · 2015

doi:10.4103/1673-5374.162689 (opens in a new tab)

We email you when a new notice or a question about this paper appears.

Abstract

Motor rehabilitation after hemiparetic stroke is essential to soften physical disability (Furlan, 2014). Nevertheless, current interventions are mostly designed for well recovered individuals and often exclude stroke survivors with rather limited motor ability (Sterr and Conforto, 2012). Given that, and further advancing our research agenda in this arena (Sterr et al., 2002; Sterr and Freivogel, 2003, 2004; Sterr, 2004; Sterr et al., 2006; Sterr and Saunders, 2006), we recently tested the efficacy of a 2-week modified constraint-induced (CI) therapy program in chronic stroke individuals with very low-functioning upper limb hemiparesis (Sterr et al., 2014a). We tested the influence of both the intensity of daily motor training (90 vs. 180 minutes) and the restraint of the less affected upper limb (restraint vs. no restraint) on treatment outcomes. Sixty-five individuals were randomly assigned to four experimental conditions (90 minutes of training with or without restraint, and 180 minutes of training with or without restraint). They were assessed at baseline and after the intervention (2 weeks before, immediately before and after, 6, and 12 months after). Across the cohort, motor function improved significantly, and treatment benefits were largely sustained over the 12 months of follow-up. Analysis of the different treatment variants, however, revealed interesting yet unexpected findings, particularly with regards to the relationship between intensity (amount) of daily training and motor outcomes. As suggested by previous work (Sterr et al., 2002), longer sessions of daily training were expected to yield better outcomes than short sessions, a finding in line with the theory that massed practice is essential for neuroplasticity processes driving the functional improvements induced by CI therapy. However, this was not entirely the case. While we found some differences suggesting greater benefit of longer training sessions, the picture was not as clear as one might expect. This pointed to an interaction between training intensity and motor outcomes in low-functioning chronic stroke that appears to be different from that seen in less severe chronic hemiparesis, where the concept of ‘the more the better’ often holds true (Figure 1). We argued that this intensity-outcome relationship is moderated by variables that highly depend on the level of residual recovery. A key candidate for this moderation is fatigue. Fatigue is identified as rather common, yet obscure problem in stroke survivors (Wu et al., 2015). Post-stroke fatigue is multifactorial and seems to result from a complex interaction among biological, psychosocial, and behavioral factors (Wu et al., 2015). Here, we discuss the role of fatigue in motor rehabilitation of low-functioning chronic stroke using the framework recently suggested by Kluger et al. (2013). Although relatively different from, yet not antithetic to other fatigue models (e.g., Wu et al., 2015), we believe their framework provides conceptual and mechanistic support to our hypothesis. According to that framework, neurological, including post-stroke fatigue encompasses two domains: Perception of fatigue and fatigability. Perception of fatigue refers to a subjective sense of effort or exhaustion, whereas fatigability is related to an objective decline in performance. Although these two types of fatigue might be largely interrelated (e.g., an increased sense of effort would usually contribute to impair performance), they might also act independently and still significantly affect the individual's engagement with activities posing high motor and/or cognitive demands. This is because those two types of fatigue are likely to be caused by different, yet potentially interacting factors. For instance, perception of fatigue could be induced by homeostatic (e.g., metabolic stimuli, such as depletion of energy reserves in skeletal muscle and/or brain tissue) and/or psychological (e.g., decreased motivation) mechanisms, while fatigability could occur due to declines in skeletal muscle force production and/or deficits in task-related neural processing (Kluger et al., 2013). Based on that, we propose that low-functioning chronic stroke survivors are highly susceptible to get into a complex fatigued state, which renders motor training ineffective. This state is more likely to be reached by individuals undergoing longer training sessions. Essentially, we elaborate here on the possibility that a combination of general deconditioning and compromised neural processing might greatly increase both perception of fatigue and fatigability in those individuals, which substantially reduces their engagement with motor training and thereby decreases the likelihood for neuroplasticity processes driving behavioral improvements.Figure 1: Hypothetical relationship between training intensity and outcomes in chronic hemiparetic stroke.This figure illustrates the modulation of the optimum session length/training intensity by residual recovery levels. Two assumptions are made. Firstly, as session length increases, performance also increases, until it reaches its peak; increasing session length further, however, results in performance deterioration, which presumably reflects the impact of fatigue. Secondly, in stroke survivors with low-functioning hemiparesis (red line), performance is not only lower in general, but critically, the optimum training intensity is reached earlier than in those with high-functioning hemiparesis (blue line). Optimum session length/training intensity: Mostly determined by both the level of residual recovery and the fatigued status an individual achieves. Of note, the latter is critically influenced by the first. Investigations of dosage effects in motor rehabilitation should, therefore, not only carefully consider the level of residual function, but also take measures of fatigue into consideration.General deconditioning in low-functioning chronic stroke: The musculoskeletal and cardiorespiratory systems are interdependent. Effective skeletal muscle work requires that muscle fibers have not only relatively good levels of strength, but also adequate supply of oxygen and nutrients. The first is achieved through regular doses of mechanical load normally imposed to the musculoskeletal system during routine tasks, while the latter is implemented by the cardiorespiratory system via the blood stream. On the other hand, to maintain an effective cardiorespiratory system that ensures adequate supply of oxygen and nutrients to working muscle fibers, regular physical activity is mandatory. This is only possible through the contraction of skeletal muscles. After hemiparetic stroke, individuals experience significant cardiorespiratory and musculoskeletal deterioration. Pre-stroke age-related changes and/or comorbid cardiovascular diseases often contribute to a deteriorated cardiorespiratory function already at the sub-acute phase (Kilbreath and Davis, 2005). In parallel, the stroke-induced loss of voluntary motor control results in an important deterioration of musculoskeletal function at the same time. More specifically, the lack of selective control over spinal motor units imposes major limitation on the individual's ability to generate muscle force and coordinate contraction across muscle groups, which critically reduces their capacity to use the paretic body side (Carr and Shepherd, 2011a). Combined to customarily low inpatient and post-discharge physical activity levels, this initial impaired cardiorespiratory and musculoskeletal status greatly increases the likelihood for an inactive lifestyle after hemiparetic stroke (Carr and Shepherd, 2011b). Over time, the sustained immobility of paretic limbs starts maladaptive plastic changes in skeletal muscles that contribute to aggravate even more an already compromised musculoskeletal condition. Some of these changes include: atrophy and shortening of muscle fibers, proliferation of connective (non-contractile) tissue, increased stiffness and fat content, and reduced capillary density and oxidative capacity (Carr and Shepherd, 2011a). Collectively, these changes further subsidise the ongoing physical inactivity process and thereby the aggravation of cardiorespiratory function (Kilbreath and Davis, 2005; Carr and Shepherd, 2011a, b). Thus, chronic stroke individuals often become trapped in a self-perpetuating cycle of general deconditioning, where an early deteriorated cardiorespiratory and musculoskeletal condition fosters physical inactivity and paretic limbs disuse, which in turn contributes to deteriorate cardiorespiratory and musculoskeletal function even further. This is likely to elevate both perception of fatigue and fatigability during motor activities by accelerating depletion of skeletal muscle energy reserves and causing rapid declines in force production, respectively. While the first is likely a compound of an impaired cardiorespiratory system – which may fail to effectively supply contracting muscles with oxygen and nutrients – and a deteriorated musculoskeletal function – in terms of reduced capillary density and oxidative capacity limiting muscle energy production –, the latter mostly results from an impaired neuro-musculoskeletal system, owing primarily to both a reduced ability to activate spinal motor units and skeletal muscle plastic changes. Of note, it is plausible to assume that general deconditioning tends to be more pronounced in low-functioning chronic hemiparesis, as here the likelihood for paretic limbs immobility and an inactive lifestyle is even higher due to greater physical (and often cognitive) limitations. Compromised neural processing in low-functioning chronic stroke: The adult brain can be thought of as having both primary, specialized, and secondary, less specialized circuits/networks. Primary circuits are critical for the generation of behavior and therefore are normally recruited. Secondary circuits, however, are not essential

Abstract licence: CC BY-NC-SA

References25

  1. 11.

24 more references, whose wording the paper’s licence keeps private.

Reads

Read by people on this page

None yet.

Checked or read by AI through naulon

None yet.

A person counts once a day per paper. We keep no cookie and no address: a reader is a hash that changes every day. Any month under five reads shows no number.

Are you an author?

Is this your paper?

Claim it to add your note and be paid when agents cite it. Free.