Skip to content
naulon
Not checkedNot checked for notices yet.

Response to Kriticos et al.

Jane Elith, Mark A. Burgman

NeoBiota · 2014

doi:10.3897/neobiota.23.7939 (opens in a new tab)

We email you when a new notice or a question about this paper appears.

Abstract

Kriticos et al. (2014) discuss a recent paper of ours (Elith et al. 2013).While we agree with several of the points they raise, in this brief response we focus on clarifying a subset of issues around improving pest risk modelling.We do so because several of their suggestions are based on misunderstandings of technical details and will not, as they hope, lead to improved modelling practice.Elith et al. (2013) used the Puccinia psidii complex as a case study to explore the impact of taxonomic uncertainty on modelled predictions.The work was clear in stating that it did not intend to provide definitive predictions and advice for biosecurity managers.This position is clear in the title and in statements in Elith et al. (2013) such as 'The purpose of this study is to explore the implications of taxonomic uncertainty for the management of a new invasive pathogen.We use the Australian incursion of myrtle/ guava rust as an example, not to argue which taxonomic interpretation, data set or model is correct, but to highlight the impact of taxonomic belief on modelled predictions.'We discussed how to make risk weighted decisions that accommodate this kind of uncertainty.We created 5 datasets of species records that were either the full set of available presence records for the P. psidii complex ("Pucc94") or subsets of that, each of which accorded with a different taxonomic interpretation.The Kriticos et al. (2014) commentary primarily uses for illustration the Pucc94 dataset (94 records) and the Ured27 dataset -a subset of Pucc94 comprising 10 records of Uredo rangelii (variously viewed as a separate species or a member of the complex) and an additional 17 records from similar environments (see Elith et al. 2013 for details).Elith et al. (2013) emphasised that "we recognise that the basis for

Abstract licence: CC BY

References11

    11 more references, whose wording the paper’s licence keeps private.

    Reads

    Read by people on this page

    None yet.

    Checked or read by AI through naulon

    None yet.

    A person counts once a day per paper. We keep no cookie and no address: a reader is a hash that changes every day. Any month under five reads shows no number.

    Are you an author?

    Is this your paper?

    Claim it to add your note and be paid when agents cite it. Free.