Pectin Methylesterases: Cell Wall Remodeling Proteins Are Required for Plant Response to Heat Stress

1Plants face challenges of extreme environmental conditions, which include various abiotic and biotic stresses, all of which exert adverse effects on plant growth and development. Being sessile organisms, plants cannot move to favorable environments; accordingly, they have developed a remarkable number of strategies to mitigate environmental impacts. Global climate change constitutes one of the most detrimental stresses to plants because it is driving an increase in ambient temperatures, which, according to the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change prediction, are expected to be 2–5°C higher than the current temperatures by the late twenty-first century. Extremely high temperatures can cause devastating damage to crops and reduce crop production; however, plant cells have been shown to have elaborate systems to respond to a variety of challenges, including HSR, which can improve crop yield under climate change conditions.

2Acquired thermotolerance in plants consists of translating an initial moderate temperature increment into molecular defenses against subsequent extreme temperatures, such as preventing and repairing damage to heat-labile proteins and membranes. HSR is characterized by the induction of a large set of HSPs, many of which comprise chaperone proteins that assist in protein folding and protect cellular homeostasis against heat and other stress stimuli. In addition to the induction of HS-responsive genes, the modification of biophysical properties of the cell wall may represent a key component in responding to environmental injuries. For example, HS at 37°C can generate changes in cell wall polymers in coffee (Coffea arabica) leaves, resulting in ∼50% decrease in pectin and 40% increase in hemicellulose. Thus, the modulation of plant cell walls, which comprise a dynamic and interconnected network consisting of a heterogeneous matrix with diverse biochemical and mechanical properties, has emerged as an important strategy in plant stress responses.

3Pectic polysaccharides are highly heterogeneous polymers involved in the control of cell wall porosity and constitute the major adhesive material between cells. When the cell is challenged with stress conditions, specific transcriptional responses affect the production of certain cell wall proteins, leading to crucial changes in cell wall architecture. Pectin modification is catalyzed by a large enzyme family of PMEs that reside in the cell wall and which modulate apoplastic Ca2+ content in response to stresses for both the assembly and disassembly of the pectic network. Thus, the maintenance of cell wall integrity is tightly controlled and strictly coordinated with the stress response in plant cells. Pectins have been identified as key elements in plant responses to either heat or cold temperature stress in various species such as winter oilseed rape (Brassica napus var. oleifera), bromeliad (Nidularium minutum), Arabidopsis (Arabidopsis thaliana), rice (Oryza sativa), soybean (Glycine max), and coffee. However, the cell wall factors that contribute to the development of plant thermotolerance remain largely unknown.

4A previous review revealed that PME-mediated changes in the cell wall have played a role in various vegetative and reproductive developmental processes in Arabidopsis and other dicotyledons. The DM of HGAs can be controlled by PMEs that have the capacity to remove methyl ester groups to contribute to the intercellular adhesion during plant development and stress responses. Thus, the DM constitutes a key element in the control of the wall stiffness and hydration status of the pectic matrix during abiotic stresses. PMEs exhibit a potential for the development of thermotolerance by maintaining apoplastic Ca2+ homeostasis. Heat-activated PME activity is involved in the cell-wall localization of Ca2+, i.e., with the removal of apoplastic Ca2+ that participates in HS signaling to induce HSP expression and cell-wall remodeling to retain plasma membrane integrity, thus preventing cellular content leakage and conferring thermoprotection. Furthermore, through the identification of Arabidopsis PME34 mutant plants, it was verified that the thermotolerance impairment of pme34 was independent from the expression of HS-responsive genes; whereas PME34 functions in controlling stomatal movements and in regulating the flexibility of the guard cell wall required for heat response.

5Little is known about the dynamics of the pectin matrix in the regulation of the impact of stress on plants. In previous research, we focused on the role of the PME, which is intrinsically involved in the modification of cell wall components in response to HS; and most recently demonstrated that the dynamic network of cell wall remodeling proteins with enzymatic activity is crucially important for cell wall tolerance to HS. The present review, therefore, describes the most recent findings regarding cell wall remodeling and HSR as well as specific issues with the characterization of PME. In addition, this review also highlights the diversity of their roles during plant development and in response to diverse abiotic stresses, particularly to HS.

6Heat stress causes a broad spectrum of cellular damage through the extensive denaturation and aggregation of proteins, and by modifying membrane permeability and fluidity, which subsequently disrupts the balance of metabolic processes. In nature, such HS conditions may be chronic or recurring, or both; therefore, plants have developed diverse systems to cope with recurring stress. HSR is a highly conserved stress response mechanism that reflects how plants respond and adapt to HS through improved thermotolerance. It defines all high temperature-related defense activities used in the cell to prevent damage and aggregation at the proteome level.

7The induction of HSPs constitutes one of the best-characterized responses in the adaptation to elevated temperature and plays an important role in the acquisition of thermotolerance. Recently, epigenetic mechanisms have been found to play important roles in the regulation of HSR, including DNA methylation, histone modification, histone variants, ATP-dependent chromatin remodeling, and siRNAs and miRNAs. For example, miRNA 156, 160, and 172 modulation of HSP gene induction is required for Arabidopsis thermotolerance. Accumulation of the heat-induced retrotransposon ONSEN, which is recognized by HS transcription factors HsfA1 and HsfA2 through its HSE, is required for the regulation of HS memory. Arabidopsis HIT4 is a chromocenter-localized protein that functions as a regulator of stress-triggered chromatin re-organization that is essential for plant heat tolerance. Therefore, it appears as if the epigenetic control of heat-responsive gene expression is frequently utilized to prevent heat-related damages. Furthermore, the emerging evidence indicates that cell wall remodeling plays a crucial role in the response to HS through the activation of cell wall-related genes and alteration of cell wall compositions. Thus, the modification of cell wall structures to enhance their functions to perceive and respond to multiple environmental stresses is crucial for plants by imparting stress endurance. We summarize the current knowledge regarding plant HSR with different aspects to integrate cellular compartments and signaling networks as addressed in Figure 1.

8The inherent ability of plants to tolerate temperatures above those that are optimal for growth is termed basal (or intrinsic) thermotolerance. Plants also have the ability to acquire tolerance to otherwise lethal HS, referred to as acquired thermotolerance (or HS priming). Specifically, mild HS primes a plant to subsequently withstand or to acclimate to high temperatures that would otherwise be lethal to an unadapted plant. This priming response of plants can be maintained over several days after mild HS and a return to normal growth conditions; which is referred to as the maintenance of acquired thermotolerance or HS memory. However, the molecular mechanisms involved in plant HS-priming and HS-memory remain largely unknown, especially for HS memory. In brief, heat stress transcription factors (HSFs) act as central regulators of HS priming by recognizing the conserved HSE in the promoter of the genes encoding HSP, which in turn guard the proteome from misfolding and aggregation under heat conditions. The HSBP is a negative regulator of HSR through the interaction with HSF and thus dissociates trimeric HSFs for the attenuation of HSR. The regulation of HSFs in response to HS is illustrated in Figure 2A.

9Four homologs of HsfA1 (HsfA1a, b, d, e) play roles of master regulators for acquired thermotolerance in Arabidopsis. HsfA2 has been shown to act as a secondary regulator under the control of HsfA1s to trigger a transcriptional cascade for the induction of early and late HS-responsive genes. Arabidopsis HsfB1 can act as a transcriptional repressor during the attenuation of HSR, whereas tomato (Solanum lycopersicum) HsfB1 possesses both coactivator and repressor functions. Two major regulators of HSR, HsfA1s and dehydration-responsive element-binding protein 2A, are controlled by other regulatory factors such as NF-YC10, Hsp90, Hsp70, and small HSP (sHSP), with regard to their activation or inactivation in the early HSR or an unstressed condition. In addition, phytohormone ABA is also involved in HS signaling through the regulation of HsfA6b for plant thermotolerance. In yeast (Saccharomyces cerevisiae), Hsf1 in collaboration with protein kinase PKC1 regulates heat-induced cell-wall genes, including CWP1, SPI1, HOR7, YGP1, and ZEO1, to mediate maintenance of cell-wall integrity under HS. Thus, yeast Hsf1 plays a role not only in the induction of HSPs expression but also in the induction of a set of cell-wall genes involved in cell-wall formation and remodeling to prevent cell lysis at high temperature. These data raise the question whether plant HSFs function as yeast Hsf1 involved in cell wall remodeling. Further work is required to determine the role of HSFs encoding a variety of other proteins that specifically function in plant cell-wall organization under HS.

10Despite the ubiquitous nature of the HSR, little is known about how plants sense an elevating temperature to transmit a signal that results in HSP induction and acquired thermotolerance. One candidate molecule that serves as a second messenger during HS signaling is calcium (Ca2+), a ubiquitous signal in eukaryotic cells. Ca2+ signals were shown to manifest through transient changes of spatio-temporal patterns of free cytosolic Ca2+ content ([Ca2+]cyt) arising from the flux of Ca2+ into the cytosol, defining the so-called Ca2+ signature. A stress-induced change in [Ca2+]cyt might constitute one of the primary transduction mechanisms whereby gene expression and biochemical events are altered to adapt to environmental stresses. The rise time, peak value, and duration of the decay back to resting levels of Ca2+ transients generated by early events have been implicated in controlling different transduction processes, including changes in gene expression. Depending on the specific activation properties, Ca2+ channels, Ca2+-ATPases, and Ca2+/H+ antiporters as modulators of Ca2+ shape the parameters and spatial characteristics of the Ca2+ flux, resulting in distinct a Ca2+ signature in response to different stress stimuli (Figure 2B).

11The stress-induced intracellular Ca2+ levels can be transmitted and sensed by a toolkit of Ca2+-binding proteins such as CaMs and their related-proteins, such as CaM-like proteins, calcineurin B-like proteins, and Ca2+-dependent protein kinases, for downstream responses. CaMs are highly conserved, consisting of two globular domains, each with two Ca2+-binding EF-hand motifs, and are considered to be multifunctional proteins. These proteins mostly act as general transducers of Ca2+-mediated signal cascades in eukaryotes submitted to various developmental and external stimuli. It was previously suggested that the transduction of environmental signals through CaM gene expression occurs in part by the elevation of [Ca2+]cyt levels. In orchard grass (Dactylis glomerata), DgHsp70, a homolog of cytosolic Hsp70, can bind to Arabidopsis CaM2 in the presence of Ca2+, whereas negative regulation of DgHsp70 decreases the ATPase and foldase activities via Ca2+/CaM binding. Furthermore, CaM is involved in HSR through the interaction with cytosolic maize (Zea mays) Hsp70 and sorghum (Sorghum bicolor) Hsp90. Increasing evidence indicates that CaM plays a crucial role in HS responses that lead to an elevation of [Ca2+]cyt signaling in various species. In wheat, CaM1-2 gene expression increases after HS at 37°C for 10 min and reaches its peak expression after 20 min HS exposure, as determined by northern analysis. In moss Physcomitrella patens, a [Ca2+]cyt elevation for 20 min was induced by HS via putative plasma membrane Ca2+-permeable channels.

12The elevated [Ca2+]cyt and CaM can directly modulate the DNA-binding activity of HSF to HSE, suggesting that they are involved in the expression of HSP genes through the regulation of HSF. Arabidopsis signal responsive 1–6 genes (SR1 to SR6), a Ca2+/CaM-binding transcription factor, play roles in transcription activation through specific binding to a “CGCG box” (A/C/G)CGCG(G/T/C) in the promoter of genes that are involved in multiple signal transduction pathways, including HSR in plants. CaM is involved in the modulation of transcription factors either through direct interaction with basic helix-loop-helix domains, or by the control of kinase-mediated phosphorylation. In transgenic Arabidopsis, reporter GUS gene expression that is directed by the Hsp18.2 promoter was shown to be affected by CaCl2 and CaM antagonists. Arabidopsis CBK3, by phosphorylating HsfA1a, enhances the binding activity to HSE, which promotes activation of HSF and HSP gene expression. Protein phosphatases, such as Arabidopsis PP7 are regulated by CaM that is dependent upon Ca2+-CaM binding, with the pp7 mutation resulting in a reduction in acquired thermotolerance. We identified the rice OsCaM1-1, whose expression resembles the biphasic [Ca2+]cyt signal, and showed that overexpression of OsCaM1-1 induced the expression of Arabidopsis Ca2+/HS-related CBK3, PP7, HSF, and HSP genes, and enhanced intrinsic thermotolerance in transgenic Arabidopsis. Thus, OsCaM1-1 interprets the Ca2+ signal by the cytosolic Ca2+ concentration and by spatio-temporal Ca2+ parameters under HS. Furthermore, OsCaM1-1 contains potential miRNA168a and miRNA408 target sites, and both miRNAs harbor HSE, which may regulate transcription of these miRNAs in response to HS.

13Extracellular CaM was found to be involved in the initiation of pollen germination and tube growth by a heterotrimeric G protein in the cellular signaling process in lily (Lilium longiflorum) pollen. However, the functions of apoplastic CaM are still poorly understood in plant cells. In Cedrus deodara, apoplastic CaM maintained the tip-focused Ca2+ gradient and modulated the distribution of pectins during pollen tube growth. Apoplastic CaM contributed to Ca2+ homeostasis and cell wall remodeling during pollen development. Thus, the interaction between Ca2+ and apoplastic CaM may play a central role in the maintenance of Ca2+ gradients for cell-wall modeling. Arabidopsis NPG1 is a pollen-specific CaM-binding protein that interacts with PLLs, suggesting NPG1 may modify the pollen cell-wall through the interaction with PLLs. In addition, the largest releasable pool of Ca2+ is localized in the cell wall, reaching approximately 60–75% of the total tissue Ca2+ content. Thus, apoplastic Ca2+ is essential for the control of cell integrity, cell wall cohesion, and plasma membrane permeability. It has been suggested that the increased [Ca2+]cyt elevation observed in transformed tobacco (Nicotiana tabacum) seedlings during HS arises from both apoplastic and cytosolic sources. Potato (Solanum tuberosum) plant growth under HS can persist at specific levels of Ca2+ in the root, providing insight into the mechanism by which the zone of root Ca2+ may modulate plant response to HS. In moss (Physcomitrella patens), a specific Ca2+-permeable channel in the plasma membrane, which regulated heat-inducible Ca2+ influx, thereby leading to HSR. Moreover, the recovery of HS-released Ca2+ is essential for the acquisition of thermoprotection to mitigate lethal HS injury both in soybean and rice seedlings.

14Notably, the cleavage of apoplastic Ca2+ bridges between pectic carboxyl groups that were created by PMEs is considered to play an important role in cell wall remodeling because it retains cell integrity during HS by preventing the plasma membrane from tearing away from the cell wall. Thus, acquired thermotolerance is reported to critically depend on a preceding Ca2+ transient through the plasma membrane so that the HSR is regulated by the transient entry of apoplastic Ca2+. Plant cells can monitor the functional integrity of cell walls, with the maintenance of cell wall integrity being an important process to relieve cellular stresses.

15The plant cell wall is a sophisticated structure formed by a complex mixture of cell wall polymers, such as polysaccharide-rich polymers, proteins, and pectin matrix that are assembled into a rigid, flexible, and dynamically organized network. Plant cell walls are multilayered and consist of three sections, including the middle lamella, primary cell wall, and secondary cell wall. The middle lamella is a pectin layer to cement the bond between two adjoining cells. The heterogeneous mixture of wall composition and thickness of the cell wall may deviate absolutely, depending on the environmental conditions. The primary wall surrounds growing cells or cells capable of cell growth; whereas the secondary wall is a highly specialized and thickened structure containing lignin, which undergoes irreversible changes in many fully developed cells. Cellulose is composed of repeating glucose residues connected through β-1,4-D-glucan (β-glucan) bonds that are crossed intricately together to form microfibrils as the scaffold of the cell wall and interconnected by hemicelluloses (xyloglucans and xylans are the most abundant) and galacturonic-acid-rich pectins (Figure 3A).

16Pectin, a highly structurally complex polysaccharide, constitutes the major component of primary cell walls for both monocots and dicots, and is important for both cellular adhesion and cell wall plasticity. For example, pectin makes up 35% of the primary cell wall in dicots and non-grass monocots, 2–10% of grass primary walls, and up to 5% of wood tissues. The middle lamella, a pectinaceous interface, depends on the formation of intermolecular links between pectin molecules and is important for the adhesion of neighboring cells. Pectins also present in the junction zone between cells within secondary walls in the xylem and fiber cells of woody tissue. Fiber length of angiosperms is determined by intrusive tip growth, which requires dissolution of the middle lamella, wall loosening between adjacent cells to create space for tip growing, and therefore, the modification of pectin may be occurring during secondary wall growth of trees. Generally, pectinaceous polysaccharides have been defined into five classes, including HGA, RG-I and -II (RG-II), XGA, and AGA; presumably, these structural elements are linked covalently to form the pectin complex as shown in Figure 3B. It is generally believed that these pectic polysaccharides are covalently linked to, or tightly associated with other types of polysaccharides, since chemical treatments or digestion by pectin-degrading enzymes are required to isolate HGA, RG-I, and RG-II from each other and from cell walls. The results support that a model of pectic polymers, HGA, RG-I, and RG-II are linked together during synthesis. For instance, the HGA backbone can be hydrolyzed by PG to produce monomeric, dimeric, or oligomeric fragments; however, HGA, RG-I, and RG-II polysaccharides failed to resolve independently by size exclusion chromatography prior to fragmentation by PG digestion. Furthermore, the stretches of α-(1,4)-linked GalA of soybean soluble polysaccharides were found flanked by RG-I fragments, providing evidence that HGA and RG-I are directly connected through backbone residues. Similarly, it has been suggested that HGA is linked to xyloglucan through fragments of XGA that were not readily solubilized from walls unless treated with PG. Therefore, the backbone of HGA is covalently linked to RG-I and RG-II. It is also hypothesized to be crosslinked to xyloglucan or possibly other wall polymers in muro. In particular, HGA is a major component of pectin and has a conformational flexibility that can be influenced by growth, development, and environmental cues. HGA consists of a linear α-1,4-linked D-GalA homopolymer, which is the most abundant pectin-rich polysaccharide, constituting 65% of the total pectin. A critical feature of HGA that influences its properties is the methyl-esterification at C6-carboxyl and acetylation at C2 or C3 position by specific HGA-modifying enzymes, which belong to large multigenic families in all sequenced species.

17Owing to the characteristics of pectic matter which form hydrophilic colloids, it has been stated that the primary cell wall is plastic and soft. This component is crucial for cell growth and expansion, and is thought to contribute to cell wall structural integrity, cell adhesion, and signal transduction. In addition, the depolymerization of cellulose and hemicellulose, along with pectin, is particularly abundant and dynamic during plant development and stress responses in terms of modifying cell-wall polysaccharides. Consequently, enzymatic cleavage of the cross-linking polysaccharides by a set of cell wall-related enzymes including β-glucosidase, XET/XTH, and PME etc., which are believed to play a role in modulating cell wall plasticity, apparently mediate cell-wall integrity during plant development and stress responses (Figure 3C). The details are described below.

18It has been proposed that plants are able to respond to a spectrum of abiotic stress conditions due to modifications in cell-wall composition and structure to perform their respective functions for the maintenance of cell-wall integrity. However, our understanding of the mechanisms of stress-induced changes in wall composition and structure is still limited. Some cell wall-related genes have been shown to contribute directly to alter cell-wall composition to maintain cell-wall integrity under abiotic stress. Abiotic stress modified cell-wall constituents by CesA enzymes which alter cellulose biosynthesis, for instance, AtCesA8/IRX1, which encodes a subunit of a CesA complex to constitute part of the cell wall, plays an important role in drought and osmotic stress responses in Arabidopsis. Arabidopsis SOS6 encodes a CesA-like protein (CSLD5) which has an important role in response to osmotic stress by regulating stress-induced ROS accumulation in plant cell walls. In barley (Hordeum vulgare), a mutation in the HvCslF6 gene that causes the loss of (1,3;1,4)-β-D-glucan reducing mixed-linkage glucan in primary cell wall yields mutants increasingly susceptible to chilling. In leaves of tomato, β-glucosidase, which is responsible for degrading cellulose to free glucose molecules, is involved in the heat-stress response. Additionally, β-glucosidase is likely involved in developing drought-tolerant wheat seedlings (cultivar Hong Mang Mai) by differentially changing cell-wall polysaccharides to favor drought tolerance.

19In coffee, arabinose and galactose contents increased, whereas mannose, glucose, uronic acid, rhamnose, and fucose contents decreased after HS. The desiccated plant Myrothamnus flabellifolius had lower amounts of arabinoxylans than those in the hydrated plant, due to the increased association between cell-wall polymers under stress. Thus, the chemical profile and structural cell-wall polymers can be modified under HS. XET/XTH and EXP family members are involved in cell wall loosening and, therefore, in cell expansion for growth and development, as well as in the regulation of the plant responses under abiotic stress. The overexpression of Capsicum annuum XTH3 in tomato showed that increased salt tolerance involved cell-wall flexibility for alleviating stress effects. In maize, some cell wall-related genes were up-regulated under salinity stress, including ZmXET1, ZmEXPA1, ZmEXPA3, ZmEXPA5, ZmEXPB1, and ZmEXPB2, to hydrolyze and rejoin xyloglucan molecules during cell-wall extension. When Arabidopsis plants were exposed to boron toxicity, the expression of genes that encode CesA (CESA1, CESA4, CESA6, and CESA8), and CesA-like CSLB5, EXPs (EXPA5, EXP8, and EXPA14) were reduced, while PMEs (PME2 and PME41) showed a different expression pattern under boron stress and/or 24-epibrassinolide treatment. Heat-tolerant, thermal Agrostis scabra, AsEXP1 was strongly induced by exposure to HS, is associated with thermotolerant grass germplasm. Overexpression of a Kentucky bluegrass (Poa pratensis) PpEXP1 in tobacco exhibited a lesser extent of structural damage to cells resulted in enhanced HS tolerance. Thus, the EXP family may play more extensive and divergent effects on cell-wall integrity during stress responses. On the other hand, Arabidopsis HOT2 encodes a CTL1 that is essential for tolerance to salt stress by preventing Na+ overaccumulation. In Chinese cabbage (Brassica rapa), several genes encoding XTH proteins, β-glucosidase, CesA, EXP, extensin, glycosyl transferase, pectin esterase, and xylosidase, are up-regulated up to two–threefold following non-lethal temperature treatment at 37°C, which enables plants to survive a subsequent lethal temperature. Thus, these results provided evidence that cell wall-related proteins or enzymes are required for the cell-wall modifications involved in thermotolerance acquisition.

20Recent studies have described that ROS and peroxidases are key players which initially cross-link phenolic compounds and extensins, causing cell-wall stiffening under drought stress. In addition, OH. radicals, which are able to cleave sugar bonds in polysaccharides, cause loosening of the cell wall similar to the action of EXPs or xyloglucan modifying enzymes. In the review by, a broader consideration was made of multiple cell wall-related genes appearing to respond to a given stimulus, and a defined set of stress-responsive transcription factors involved in transcriptional regulation. However, a specific target for cell-wall modifications due to different stress responses has to be explored in detail, especially in distinct species.

21It has been reported that HGA-type pectins play crucial roles in mediating the modification of cell wall mechanical properties and controlling turgor-induced plant morphogenesis through the action of pectinolytic enzymes. In plants, pectinolytic enzymes or pectinases, which act by hydrolysis of pectic substances through the reactions of depolymerization (hydrolases and lyases) and deesterification (esterases), comprise a heterogeneous group of enzymes, including PMEs, PAEs, PGs, and PLs (Figure 3C). The acetyl- and methyl-esterifications of pectins represent the key parameters for the regulation of cell wall mechanical properties. HGA chains can be deacetylated in muro by PAE, with the resulting acetylester change dynamically impacting plant growth and development. It has been demonstrated that the deacetylation of pectin can lower the hydrophobicity of the polysaccharide backbone to increase pectin solubility in water. Thus, PAEs are a crucial structural factor can protect polysaccharides against enzymatic digestion. Black cottonwood (Populus trichocarpa) that overexpress PtPAE1 exhibit disturbed pollen tube elongation and severe male sterility; however, PtPAE1-mediated deacetylation has been shown to lower the digestibility of pectin. Following the identification of the Arabidopsis PAE family, it was found that pae8 and pae9 mutants led to ∼20% increase in acetate accumulation in cell walls leading to the reduction in inflorescence growth. Arabidopsis acetylation 2 (rwa2) mutation, which displayed a 20% reduction in cell-wall acetylation, was observed to increased resistance to Botrytis cinerea. When Medicago truncatula was grown in a CO2 enriched atmosphere, PAE genes were induced in response to aluminum stress and were associated with aluminum resistance. In addition, data retrieved from the eFP Browser1 showed that Arabidopsis PAE2 and PAE4 were induced in response to osmotic and salt stress.

22Furthermore, the synthesis of HGA with a high methyl ester at C6 carboxyl residues occurs in the Golgi, which is then further exported into the cell wall in a highly methyl-esterified form of 70 ∼ 80% methylesterification. The action of PME temporally and spatially regulates the fine control of the DM, i.e., the hydrolysis of the methylester bond at the C-6 position of GalA in HGA, and is potentially involved in the regulation of cell wall architecture and determination of the methylesterification status of pectin. The increase of PME activity and DM are attributed to aluminum resistance in the root transition zone in pea (Pisum sativum). A limited number of investigations on the patterns of PME action in response to abiotic stresses suggest that this area is largely unknown. Thus, in subsequent discussion we focus on the function of PME to alter cell wall properties through the modification of different wall components, which plays an important role in the response to adverse environments, especially to heat exposure.

23Pectin methylesterases (EC 3.1.1.11), which belong to class 8 (CE8) of the carbohydrate esterases (CAZy website2), and whose activity is regulated by PMEIs, modify the DM of pectins. In the Arabidopsis genome, 66 ORFs have been annotated as putative PME genes that are distinctively expressed; furthermore, 89 and 80 PME ORFs correspond to the protein-coding genes in the poplar (Populus spp.) and Asiatic cotton (Gossypium arboreum) database, respectively. Conversely, fewer PME genes, as represented by 43 putative ORFs, were found in rice (O. sativa subsp. Japonica cv.; ) compared to those of dicots, which may be related to the differences in the structure of the respective cell wall, such as less methyl esterified HGA in grass species.

24Depending on PME structure, Arabidopsis PMEs are frequently organized with an N-terminal extension of PRE and PRO sequence. PMEs can be classified into types I and II based on their presence or absence of the PRO domain. Type I is characterized by the presence of the N-terminal PRO region, which show homology with PMEI domains, whereas type II is characterized by the absence of the PRO region (Figure 4A). The export of PME to the cell wall via the PRE domain, which can be mediated by a signal peptide or a transmembrane domain (TM or signal anchor), is required for protein targeting. The PRO-region is required for correct targeting of the cell wall and supports an autoinhibitory activity of enzymes necessary for secretion of the mature PME to the apoplast. Type-II PME without the PRO-region and with five or six introns, has a similar structure to that of phytopathogenic organisms, such as fungi and bacteria. The localization of tobacco type-I PME, NtPPME1, was shown using a full-length product fused with GFP that is specifically expressed in the cell wall of pollen, whereas NtPPME1 lacking the PRO-region was maintained in the cytoplasm, suggesting that the PRO-region of NtPPME could assist the correct targeting of the mature PME. The TM domain of tobacco PME Q9LEBO assists in the transport of PME to the cell surface and its export to the cell wall; however, the PRO-region of Q9LEBO does not affect targeting to the cell wall.

25Pectin methylesterases function in de-esterification of the methylated carboxyl group (COOCH3) of pectin to form elastic pectins and accompany MeOH generation during division and maturation of the plant cell. Three modes of action of mature PMEs on polysaccharides have been proposed: single-chain, multiple-chain, and multiple-attack mechanisms. In the single-chain mechanism, the activity of PME converts all substrate sites on the polymeric chain. In the multiple-chain mechanism, PME catalyzes one reaction and then dissociates from the substrate, whereas PME catalyzes many cycles of reaction before the enzyme-polysaccharide complex dissociates in the multiple-attack mechanism. Both single-chain and multiple-attack mechanisms have been proposed in plant and bacterial PMEs as these produce contiguous regions of GalAs. Conversely, the random attack of fungal PMEs has been reported to be a multiple-chain mechanism.

26During cell wall formation, HGA is de-methylesterified by the activity of PME, which results in contiguous and random patterns of free carboxylic residues. The contiguous demethylesterification of PME (by single-chain or multiple-attack mechanism) leads to large amounts of demethylesterified GalA, the negatively charged chains of which can bind to Ca2+ to promote the formation of “egg box” structures and play a significant role in the structural rigidity of the cell wall. Their enzymatic activity can be modulated by different optimal pH values to further shift the mode of action to random demethylesterification. Random demethylesterification (as a multiple-chain mechanism) releases protons that become a target for pectin-degrading enzymes such as PG (EC 3.2.1.15), which act by hydrolyzing the α-1,4 link between GalA. PG acts co-operatively with PME to disassemble the pectin polymer networks and contribute to cell wall weakening. This observation has been confirmed by the combination of PME and PG activity causing an increased opening of stomatal aperture in both maize and Asiatic dayflower (Commelina communis). However, incubation of PG alone did not show the effect on stomata opening, indicating that the methylesterified HGA is crucial for guard cell wall movement. Under salt stress, the increased demethylesterified pectins mediated by PME activity tend to crosslink with the Ca2+, leading to solidification of the cell wall and decreased growth. Hence, the degree of pectin methyl-esterification affects Ca2+ cross-linking and pectate gel formation, which has dramatic consequences on cell wall texture and mechanical properties, thereby regulating cellular growth, cell shape, and defense reactions in plants.

27In addition, the activity of PME is closely regulated by its endogenous inhibitor proteins, PMEIs, during plant development and growth. The additional PRO domain in type-I PME genes shares similarities with the PMEI domain of PMEI genes. PMEIs belong to plant invertase inhibitor-related proteins, and as inhibitors, they play an important role in the regulation of metabolic enzymes. A transgenic Arabidopsis that constitutively expresses AtPMEI-1 or AtPMEI-2 demonstrates a significant reduction in PME activity and increased levels of pectin methylesterification. Overexpression of a novel AtPMEI has a direct, profound effect on the activity of PME. Furthermore, increased PMEI accumulation significantly improved plant resistance to the fungal pathogens Botrytis cinerea, Bipolaris sorokiniana, and Fusarium graminearum. The pepper (Capsicum annuum) CaPMEI gene, when overexpressed in Arabidopsis, enhances tolerance to Pseudomonas syringae pv. tomato, mannitol, and methyl viologen. In addition, the overexpression of PMEI limits the movement of tobamovirus (tobacco mosaic virus) in tobacco and Arabidopsis, and reduces plant susceptibility to the virus. Arabidopsis PME3 and PMEI7 were shown to have overlapping expression patterns in the etiolated hypocotyls when undergoing HGA methylesterification during plant development. Overexpression of Arabidopsis PME5 and PMEI3 resulted in softer and harder shoot apical meristem cell walls, respectively. Thus, the regulation of PMEI genes in the function of PME has a connection with plant development, defense, and stress response including wounding, drought, and oxidative and osmotic stresses.

28Pectin methylesterases play an important role in both pectin remodeling and disassembly of the cell wall, and, therefore are involved in many physiological processes, including microsporogenesis, pollen germination, tube growth, pollen separation, seed germination, root development, stem elongation, polarity of leaf growth, and fruit softening during post-harvest fruit ripening. Moreover, over the past few years, several loss-of-function phenotypes of Arabidopsis PME have been described, as shown in Figure 4B and Table 1.

29QUARTET1 (QRT1) assists in the liberation of pollen grains from tetrads during floral development. VANGUARD1 (VGD1) and PPME1 (PME9) promote pollen tube growth. PME-mediated de-methylesterification is thought to be required to render HGA susceptible to PG-mediated degradation; for example, PME QRT1 potentially acts in tandem with PG QRT3 to degrade de-methylesterified HGA in pollen mother cell primary walls. AtPME35 is responsible for the demethylesterification of pectins and is involved in regulating the mechanical strength of the supporting tissue in Arabidopsis inflorescence stems. AtPME6 is abundant during mucilage secretion, acting on embryo morphology and mucilage extrusion, both of which are involved in embryo development. In addition, AtPME58 is specifically expressed in mucilage secretory cells and plays a role in mucilage structure and organization. PMEs also act as positive regulators in the control of cell elongation in dark-growth Arabidopsis hypocotyls. AtPME17 was highly co-expressed with and processed by a subtilisin-type serine protease AtSBT3.5 to release a mature apoplastic PME isoform that was involved in root development and in response to various stresses. Pectin content, PME activity, and pectin demethylesterification are also involved in H2O2-induced cell expansion and in determining the root diameter of rice root tips.

30Additionally, the DM of HGA settled by PME constitutes an important decisive factor of the biological activity of OG-related signaling and the formation of MeOH, leading to the elicitation of plant defense responses. The higher degree of pectin methylesterification is less susceptible to hydrolysis by fungal endo-PG, and, therefore, highly methylesterified pectin can trigger plant resistance to pathogenic fungi. Several studies have reported that PME interaction with a virus-encoded MP is required for tobamovirus, turnip vein clearing virus, and cauliflower mosaic virus infection, mediating cell-to-cell movement of the virus through the plasmodesmata. AtPME3 interacts with the cellulose binding protein of the cyst nematode Heterodera schachtii and enhances the susceptibility of the plant to nematodes. Furthermore, AtPME3 acts as a susceptibility factor and is necessary for the initial colonization by necrotrophic pathogens B. cinerea and Pectobacterium carotovorum. Moreover, PME-mediated pectin methyl de-esterification may influence the mediated release of pectin-derived compounds, which in turn elicits a defense response. Thus, the specific effect of PME in the pattern of pectin methylesterification plays a determinant role in plant immunity. Overall, the study of PME genes revealed a considerable compatibility and differential control of regulatory pathways in plants.

31In addition, some studies have described for the importance of pectin in secondary cell wall formation and modification. Pectin-associated β-1,4-galactans are detected in the secondary walls of tension and compression wood. The occurrence of the pectin RG-II in the most primitive extant vascular plant groups (e.g., Pteridophytes, Lycophytes, and Bryophytes), is correlated with the upright growth of developed lignified secondary walls in vascular plants. Additional evidence provided a clearer link between pectin modification and secondary wall formation. The expression of PMEs are involved in the expanding wood cells of poplar, and in the stem, phloem, and xylem of Eucalyptus globulus. Arabidopsis mutant lacking PME35 has been shown reduced the mechanical integrity in their stem interfascicular fibers. Hence, pectin plays a role in the early stages of secondary wall deposition and has a fundamental role in secondary wall structure and function. However, the ability of cells to adapt to environmental changes through the regulation of PME-mediated modification in secondary cell wall for wall integrity maintenance remains a major challenge.

32To date, numerous studies have revealed that PME participates in the regulation of plant development by affecting the mechanical properties of the plant cell walls; however, little is known regarding the role of PME in abiotic stresses. The effects of temperature stress on the cell wall may be revealed at various levels such as cell wall architecture and composition. It has been shown that pectin contents are related to temperature-dependent modifications, and that the DM of pectins is also involved in temperature responses.

33Available data support the idea that cell wall-modifying enzymes are involved in temperature stress responses. For example, in winter oil-seed rape, the cold temperature-dependent pectin modification through the regulation of pectin methylesterification degree causes a retardation in leaf expansion that is correlated with the development of cold acclimation and fungus resistance. In the leaves of chilling-sensitive CM109 maize (Z. mays spp. indentata, dent), low temperatures of ∼14°C/12°C (day/night) result in a reduction of pectin contents and PME activity, especially after prolonged treatment for 28 h and 7 days. High temperatures of 35–65°C cause an activation of PME activity and the formation of MeOH in the intact tissue of green bean and tomato. In winter oilseed rape, HS-induces a nearly 10-fold reduction in PME35 (EV193389) gene expression. In tomato pollen, HsfA2 is an important coactivator of HsfA1a during HSR; in addition, in developing anthers of A2AS transgenic plants with suppressed HsfA2 level, approximately 25% of the genes have function codes assigned for cell wall-modifying enzymes (including several PME, PAE, and PL) under non-stress conditions. It has been suggested that cell wall-related genes might be directly regulated by HsfA2. Thus, cell wall-related genes might be regulated by HS-associated gene expression in HSR. The demethylesterification rate of PME activity was increased substantially with increasing temperature, although the mechanism for temperature activation is less understood.

34Polysaccharides and pectin present as a Ca2+-pectate gel are embedded in the primary-cell-wall matrix, providing an enormous Ca2+ reservoir. Pectin contains largely demethylesterified HGA sequences cross-linked through Ca2+ bridges to form egg-box structures, which are responsible for maintaining the integrity of the pectic network. The distribution of Ca2+ at the cell wall is mainly the result of a plethora of binding sites for Ca2+ in the cell wall, as well as the carefully regulated transport of Ca2+ into the cytoplasm. Elevated temperature may cause a loss of cell membrane integrity, which allows Ca2+ leakage out from the cells into the cell wall to activate PME activity. It is possible that, at elevated temperatures, some changes may occur in the PME enzyme that converts it to a different or more active form or that its activity may be increased by the presence of Ca2+ and other cations. In previous studies, we verified that fine-tuning of an apoplastic Ca2+ mechanism was associated with PME activity on the pectin methylesteri?cation status by immunolocalization analyses of Ca2+-demethylated HGA during HSR and EGTA chelator treatment. The removal of apoplastic Ca2+ might participate in HS signaling to induce HS protein expression and cell-wall remodeling to retain plasma membrane integrity, prevent leakage of cellular content and confer thermoprotection. The blossom-end rot (BER) is a Ca2+-related physiological disorder that occurs in tomato fruit. It has been shown that a reduced level of PME expression and activity directly determine a correlation with changes in cellular Ca2+ partitioning and distribution in fruits, leading to fruit susceptibility to BER development. The effect of PME expression and activity on the amount of esterified pectins and Ca2+ bound to the cell wall is an important factor for plant development and stress responses. Thus, the tight control of the DM of pectin and the formation of Ca2+ cross-linkage appears to play a major role in plant growth and act as a regulator in response to heat.

35The action of PME and the level of Ca2+ availability within the apoplasm has a direct impact on cell wall strength and expansion. Because the Ca2+ binding to uronic acids is easy to exchange for H+, this reaction may be involved in the acid-induced extension of the cell wall. Therefore, the carboxyl groups of pectin likely interact with the charged H+ atom that functions to acidify and loosen the cell wall to reduce injury. The cell corners, which contribute to cell adhesion via Ca2+ cross-linking, bear greater tension and support the conductivity of mechanical stresses throughout the plant tissue. Cleavage of the Ca2+ bridges between pectic carboxyl groups in the cell wall is important for cell-wall remodeling during stresses. This suggests that the cell wall regulates the level of Ca2+ concentration to make the cell more “relaxed,” thereby increasing the capability to avoid the plasma membrane from detaching from the cell wall. The extra Ca2+ is mobilized into the cytoplasm through Ca2+ channels that were opened by depolarization. The extracellular influx of Ca2+ is governed by changes in the ion binding properties within the cell wall rather than movements across the plasma membrane. Moreover, pectin gel strength increases with increasing Ca2+ concentration but decreases with increased temperature and acidity. Thus, the cell wall needs to eliminate Ca2+ and maintain low-level apoplastic Ca2+ during HS, resulting in increasing Ca2+ levels in the cytoplasm for regulating intracellular levels in response to HS.

36Because MeOH is a product of PME action, it might serve as a volatile signal in the protection of photosynthetic machinery from photo-inhibition; stimulating the growth of C3 plants and the signaling of plant-herbivore interactions for plant defense mechanisms. Furthermore, MeOH activates various patterns of gene expression that are involved in detoxification and signaling pathways, including the induction of HSP genes. The OGs, as pectin fragments related to PME activities that act as elicitors to stimulate the production of ROS, plasma membrane depolarization, and increased inositol triphosphate and [Ca2+]cyt, have been widely reported in plants. It has been shown that the extracellular domain of WAK1, which functions as a potential sensor of cell wall signaling by directly binding to the Ca2+ crosslinking pectin-derived OGs, is involved in cell growth, cell expansion, and disease resistance. The heat-activated PME participates in pectin remodeling, which in turn keeps cells from separating and maintains plasma-membrane integrity, prevents cellular leakage, and coordinates with HS signaling to confer thermoprotection. Together, these findings suggest that homeostasis of the apoplastic [Ca2+] through the regulation of PME activity during HSR might have a pronounced effect on the development of heat tolerance by preventing cellular leakage through Ca2+-pectate remodeling in the cell wall.

37Guard cells comprise a highly developed system that is used to determine and characterize the mechanism of the early signal transduction pathway in plants. In particular, they are involved in gas exchange between the interior of the plant and the external environment through the regulation of successive openings and closures of the stomatal pore. Guard cells perceive a multitude of endogenous and environmental stimuli including hormonal stimuli, light, humidity, CO2 concentration, drought, and temperature to trigger cellular responses resulting in stomatal opening or closure. High temperature increases the risk of heat damage and water shortage to plants. In response to elevated temperatures, transpiration occurs through the opening of stomatal apertures to facilitate cooling of the leaf surface through water evaporation (Figure 5A). In contrast, drought can cause stomatal closure and reduce transpiration rates; therefore, stomatal control is considered to be a short-term dynamic adaptation to avoid the reduction in leaf water potential.

38Immunolocalization analyses of Arabidopsis leaf sections indicate highly methylesterified and Ca2+ cross-linked de-esterified HGA in mesophyll cells, whereas unesterified HGA constitutes the predominant form of pectin in guard-cell walls, leading the stomatal closure response. Arabidopsis PME6 and polygalacturonase involved in expansion 3 (PGX3) in the guard cells play an important role in response to stomatal opening/closure control. In a previous study, heat-exposed rice plants exhibited lower stomatal conductance until harvest, which can affect carbon balance, grain-filling processes, and yield production. In C. communis, it has been shown that a 40°C HS for 5 min in roots could lead to a significant decrease in stomatal conductance, indicating that the communication between root and shoot is mediated by long-distance signaling. In Mimosa pudica, heat stimulation triggers rapid hydro-passive stomatal opening and subsequent stomatal closure that is concomitant with a loss of net CO2 uptake.

39The highly specialized walls of guard cells enable them to undergo large and reversible deformation during the constriction of stomata. Therefore, it is possible that cell wall modification factors are involved in controlling stomata apertures. Recently, we found that Arabidopsis PME34 deficiency causes lower transpiration rates owing to an abnormal stomatal opening, leading to higher leaf temperatures and enhanced sensitivity to heat. The type-I PME gene PME34, which encodes a plasma membrane-localized and a cell wall deposited protein, functions during guard cell wall modification in response to heat. PME34 mutants have been shown to be hypersensitive to heat but independent of HSF-mediated HSP gene transcriptional activation. The PME34 transcript was induced by ABA and highly expressed in guard cells, indicating that PME34 is associated with ABA-dependent stomatal movement in response to heat. High PME activity coincided with an increase in PG activity in pme34 plants, degrading pectin more easily, and further influencing the ability of guard cell walls to be modified in response to heat. This may support the idea proposed by, who suggested that different PME isoforms exhibit distinct action patterns and pectic substrate specificity in response to HS. As highly methylesterified pectins are less susceptible to the action of PG, HS might render the cell wall to be more acidic so that it could stimulate the random demethylesterification activity of PME and promote the action of PG on pectin cleavage, further influencing the structural characteristics of guard cell walls for stomatal movement. Notably, the absence of PME34 activity in guard cells may be complemented by other PMEs and an integration with PG action to bring about the wide opening of stomata pores (Figure 5B).

40Thus, PME34 may have a role in crosslinking with pectic polymers in the cell wall to regulate the flexibility of guard cell walls. Although PME functions to remove the methylester group from HGA to prevent stomatal opening, loss of PME34 resulted in wider stomata under lethal heat treatment. This is consistent with the observation that during drought stress, pme6 mutants have a significantly cooler leaf temperature than the wild-type plants, as well as a more restricted response to ABA. The pme34 mutant displayed a defect in the control of stomatal movement with a concomitant increase in leaf temperature. It also showed a higher transpiration rate through the more widely open stomata, which was probably due to the altered pectin methylesterification status of the guard cell wall properties. Thus, PME34 functions in controlling stomatal movements and in regulating the flexibility of the guard cell wall, which is required for the heat response. The impact of loss of PME34 on stomatal aperture may be due to Ca2+ signaling or oligosaccharides released during cell-wall modification, or both, which requires further investigation.

41Although fine-tuning of the methylesterification of pectin through the regulation of PME activity during plant growth is relatively well understood, very little is known about stress-induced alterations of cell-wall polymers with respect to PME activity. Analysis of the patterns of pectin methylesterification in pme mutants is important to distinguish the distinct roles of individual PME genes. The evidence from genetic and transgenic plants indicated that the modification of cell wall remodeling has a pronounced effect on stress tolerance. The adjustment of the cell wall through the activity of PME under abiotic stresses is a critical determinant of plant adaptation. The change in cell wall metabolism and cell wall-modifying enzyme activity in controlling cell wall plasticity is an important physiological mechanism of plants in response to heat. The stress effect on the architecture of cell wall remodeling by PME activity may depend on the plant species, genotype, and growth stage, and also rely on the intensity and timing of the stress. In addition, the specificity of PMEI toward different PME isoforms can directly modulate the endogenous PME activity during plant development and various stress responses. In particular, complex interaction between PMEs and their inhibitors appears to be involved in a complex metabolic network and the regulation of gene expression pathways during plant growth and development as well as in stress adaptation. The additional complexity of the interaction of PME with other cell-wall proteins to render a load-bearing, yet extensible primary cell wall during stress, remains an elusive issue. Much remains to be elucidated as to how the cell wall senses and transduces the signals leading to stress-induced transcriptional machinery changes and the underlying cell-wall polysaccharide deposition and modification. The role of cell wall-related genes, such as WAKs, which directly bind pectin polymers and partially depend upon the DM of pectin, and polysaccharides, has been explored during various stages of plant development. The qualitative and quantitative assessment of cell wall composition at the single cell level is also required. In particular, we need to elucidate single-cell responses to certain environmental changes. For instance, in the root cells of Arabidopsis, transcriptional changes were found to be directly related to alternations of cell-wall composition, indicating that transcript abundance is followed by associated cell-wall modifying enzymes and proteins. Further, it is required to establish a direct connection between pectin modification and secondary wall formation by identifying and determining the function of pectin-related genes. Consequently, PME-mediated deesterification could be a crucial mechanism for contributing the secondary wall growth of wood development. Likewise, the transcriptional regulation of pectin-modifying genes might be an important aspect of secondary cell wall formation attributed to both abiotic and microbial challenges. These insights provide a foundation for further research such as transcriptomics studies that may reveal details of the cell wall machinery and stress-responsive transcription factors to provide targets and strategies to facilitate plant adaptation to HS.

42H-CW and T-LJ conceived and wrote the manuscript. VB contributed to the final version of the manuscript.

43The authors declare that the research was conducted in the absence of any commercial or financial relationships that could be construed as a potential conflict of interest.