Food related processes in the insular cortex

1The insular cortex is embedded in the lateral sulcus of the mammalian brain. On the basis of cytoarchitectonic studies using myelin staining techniques, the insula can be subdivided in three major compartments according to the laminar structure, referred to as the anterior ventral agranular, dorsal anterior dysgranular, and posterior granular part of the insular cortex (Mesulam and Mufson,; Gallay et al., ). The agranular anterior insula in junction to the caudal orbitofrontal cortex (OFC) and the adjacent frontal operculum has been identified as the primary taste cortex (Rolls, ). Besides multiple perceptive inputs of gustational cues (smell, taste, temperature, viscosity, texture) in the anterior insula and hence different pathways, additional granular and dysgranular regions especially the dorsal mid-insula are involved in gustation (De Araujo and Simon,; Kurth et al., ). Their close interconnections with the OFC indicate that this part plays a predominant role in the evaluation of motivational states and primary reinforcers (Wager and Barrett, ). Also functional connectivity based analyses highlight the anterior part of the insular cortex as a major hub in cerebral processing of cognitive, emotional, motivational, and sensory stimuli, and, defines together with the anterior cingulate cortex (ACC) the salience network (Menon and Uddin, ). The anterior dysgranular part is superior to the agranular part bounded on the border to the frontal operculum. This part is particularly engaged during tasks requiring executive control, shifting attention, and working memory (Wager and Barrett, ). The intermediate part of the insula and its dysgranular laminar structure extending into the parietal operculum is strongly connected with all parts of the insula and is involved in motor, somatosensory, and pain processing (Kurth et al., ). Hence, neuroanatomical findings indicate that the insular cortex is an important structure on the transition between allocortex and isocortex, hinting to the involvement in a wide range of sensory, emotional, and cognitive processing of gustatory stimuli.

2The insular cortex is integrated in a distinct network responsible for the neural control of appetite and the regulation of energy balance. Whereas the hypothalamus represents the major homeostatic player, the insular cortex is integrated in the neural system which is involved in the processing of external sensory information tightly linked to reward processing (Berthoud, ). Therefore, the insular cortex activity also contributes to the hedonic system.

3Several neuroimaging studies emphasized the functional contribution of the anterior insula in gustatory perception (Small et al.,; Veldhuizen et al.,; Figure 1A), which is represented in the processing of visually presented (Porubska et al.,; Frank et al., ), tasted or smelled food stimuli (De Araujo et al., ), and also in food craving (Pelchat,; Pelchat et al., ). Eating per se is a multimodal experience, including taste, olfaction, smell, and somatosensory inputs (De Araujo and Simon, ). As part of the primary taste and primary olfactory cortex (Rolls,; Small, ), the anterior insula is also highly responsive to different flavors (Rolls,; Small,; Small and Green, ). Sensory food-related inputs are combined in the anterior insula (Small, ), resulting in increased activation of this region after stimulation with a specific flavor (Small et al., ). Small and Prescott describe overlapping activation in the anterior insula after independent stimulation with taste and odor cues. Besides the taste component, transferred from the taste buds on the tongue to the primary taste cortex, the aroma of food is also experienced olfactorily via the retronasal route (Ruijschop et al.,; Small and Green, ).

4Also, the texture and viscosity of ingested food is represented in the anterior and mid-insular cortex. Here, the activation changes according to the viscosity of a stimulus (De Araujo and Rolls,; Alonso et al., ).

5Besides components like taste, aroma and texture, also the amount of fat influences the activity in this gustatory and hedonic region. A recent fMRI study (Frank et al., ), investigating the effect of a high- and low-fat meal on the cerebral blood flow, revealed a differential influence of fat on the mid-anterior insular cortex and the hypothalamus. The activity in the hypothalamus, representing the homeostatic system in the brain, decreased after intake of a high-fat meal, whereas the insular cortex activity increased after intake of the low-fat meal. This suggests an interaction of the homeostatic and the gustatory system, which might be mediated by the fat content of the meal.

6The processing of food also includes the internal evaluation of the ingested, seen or smelled nutrients. The evaluative component includes interoceptive awareness, which is as well associated with insular processing (Craig, ). On a behavioral level, it was shown that good cardiac awareness, as a marker of interoception, is inversely related to the experienced fullness and myoelectric gastric activity after water load (Herbert et al., ). On the neuronal level, gastric distention without actual food intake leads to increased activation in the posterior insular cortex (Wang et al., ). Such findings corroborate the integrative function of the insular cortex.

7A recent meta-analysis by Brooks et al. report decreased activation in obese compared to lean subjects in the mid-insular cortex, a region shown to be involved in interoceptive awareness (Simmons et al., ). The reduced awareness of the bodily state and, therefore, also for appetite signals of the gut and brain might be a reason for obese to consume more food in order to feel the interoceptive cues from the body in the same way normal-weight people do (Brooks et al., ).

8Craig already proposed laterality differences in introceptive perception related to emotional processing. In a previous study a stronger impairment in taste functions in patients suffering from a lesion in the left anterior insular cortex compared to patients with a lesion in the right anterior insula (Stevenson et al., ), was shown. Furthermore, there is evidence that pleasant odors are rather processed in the left hemisphere and unpleasant odors in the right hemisphere (Henkin and Levy, ). However, further evidence is needed to understand possible hemispheric relationships of insular functions in more detail.

9It has been shown that bulimia nervosa (BN) patients exhibit increased insula activation to high-caloric food pictures in comparison to overweight and normal weight control subjects (Schienle et al., ). This difference is possibly due to the enhanced autonomic arousal that appetizing food pictures elicit in BN. Increased insula activation was also shown in anorexia nervosa (AN) patients compared to healthy subjects when contrasting pictures of high- versus low-calorie drinks (Nunn et al.,; Figure 1E). In contrast, after the ingestion of chocolate milk in a hungry state, AN patients exhibited less activation in the insula than control subjects (Vocks et al., ). Of special importance is the change in insula function when women recovered from AN or BN. While AN recovered patients showed a decreased anterior insula activity after drinking sweet tastes (Wagner et al.,; Oberndorfer et al., ), BN recovered patients revealed an enhanced insula response in relation to weight matched controls (Oberndorfer et al., ). The different activation patterns may result from an altered processing of hunger or reward signals and a misinterpretation of internal feeling and feeding states that lead to exaggerated or restricted eating behavior even after treatment.

10Neuroimaging studies investigating food processing, by means of visual stimulation, have shown enhanced insula activity in obese compared to lean subjects (Figure 1B). Specifically, obese subjects were found to show higher left anterior and right mid-insular activity compared to lean control subjects in respone to food cues (Scharmuller et al., ). Also, Rothemund et al. and Stoeckel et al. reported enhanced activation in response to high-caloric food pictures in obese women in the anterior insula. In adolescent girls, the activation in the anterior insula correlated positively with the BMI during the orientation to food cues (Yokum et al., ). Studies investigating linear relationships of BMI with brain functions showed heightened activity in the anterior insula and the adjacent frontal operculum with increasing BMI (Ziauddeen et al., ).

11Beside visual stimulation with food items, studies using oral food cues have also shown the insular cortex to be vital for food intake. While hunger resulted in a regional cerebral blood flow (rCBF) increase after administration of 2 mL of drinking water, satiation has been associated with a decrease in insular rCBF, suggesting that the reaction of the insular cortex to sensory experiences is affected by hunger (Del Parigi et al.,; Figure 1C). However, this decrease after satiation was more pronounced in obese compared to lean subjects (Gautier et al.,, ). Additionally, obese subjects revealed an enhanced sensory experience in the mid-dorsal insula to a liquid meal after a prolonged fast (Delparigi et al., ). Concomitantly, these results point to abnormal gustatory processing in obesity in response to a meal as well as to the sensory processing of food. The combination of a sweetened drink with the stimulation with food pictures also revealed enhanced anterior insula activation in obese subjects (Connolly et al., ), supporting the integration of multimodal stimuli in this area. Generally, the anterior insular cortex is highly responsive to food intake and anticipated food intake, a response that is more pronounced in obese (Stice et al.,, ).

12Besides changes in activity, the insular cortex also revealed significant changes in functional connectivity in obese compared to lean subjects during resting-state and in response to food cues (Figure 1D). As such, the anterior insula has significant functional connections to several frontal, temporal, and parietal areas, in particular to the OFC, inferior frontal cortex and to the ACC in normal weight subjects (Taylor et al.,; Deen et al., ). In contrast, obese subjects revealed decreased functional connectivity in the insular cortex during resting-state (Kullmann et al., ), and increased functional and effective connectivity in response to food cues especially to striatal regions (Garcia-Garcia et al.,; Nummenmaa et al.,; Kullmann et al., ).

13When facing the problem of obesity, one pressing question is how to effectively lose and maintain body weight. Successful weight loss maintainers show a greater bilateral insula response after orosensory stimulation with food cues (Sweet et al., ). Interestingly, the response to visually presented food items in the insular cortex seems to be predictive for the weight loss outcome. Less successful patients in a weight loss program showed higher insular activation pre- and post-treatment (Murdaugh et al., ). After successful weight-loss maintenance achieved by bariatric surgery, neuroimaging studies have shown that brain activations after food intake or visual stimulation with food cues are comparable with lean subjects (Van De Sande-Lee et al.,; Frank et al., ). Also in motivational and reward-related regions (including the insular cortex) stimulation with food pictures showed decreased activation after gastric banding (Bruce et al., ).

14Regarding the increasing prevalence for obesity and the frequent failure of weight maintenance after weight loss, new therapeutic approaches are urgently needed. Therefore, it is intriguing to speculate about possible biofeedback strategies. Food-specific electrodermal biofeedback leads to increased food-related self-efficacy and reduced perceived stress (Teufel et al., ). Morewedge et al. reported that food consumption can be reduced by thoughts for food in lean subjects. The focus on food during eating enhances memory for a meal to later time points and reduce later food intake (Higgs and Donohoe, ). One innovative approach that might support the effort of obesity treatment is an fMRI-based neurofeedback training, which allows the voluntary regulation of specific brain regions (Birbaumer et al., ). Considering the multimodal functions of the insular cortex and its importance for food reward, the anterior insula seems to be an appropriate target for real-time fMRI (rtfMRI) neurofeedback. In a previous rtfMRI study, addressing the anterior insular cortex as the region of interest (ROI), lean participants learned to regulate this region voluntarily within one day over four training sessions (Caria et al., ). In a follow-up study, this group demonstrated that successful regulation compared to no regulation of the anterior insular cortex resulted in increased negative valence ratings of emotional pictures (Caria et al., ). Furthermore, it was shown that effective connectivity between the anterior insular cortex and areas involved in emotional processing were strongest in the best regulation session (Veit et al., ). In a recent study, we addressed insular neurofeedback training in obese subjects (Frank et al., ). During the training sessions, all obese participants were able to regulate the activity, whereas four out of eleven participants of the lean group were not able to successfully regulate the anterior insula (Figure 1F). Investigating underlying neural connectivity processes, lean regulators in comparison to obese regulators showed stronger functional connectivity in cingular and temporal cortices during regulation. Therefore, lean and obese subjects seem to recruit differential neural networks to perform a voluntary regulation of primary gustatory systems.

15In conclusion, the insular cortex, especially the anterior part, is a multimodal and integrative area for the processing of food-related items. Central gustatory processes are tightly linked to interoception represented in reduced awareness of bodily signals including satiety signals. Therefore, interoception is associated with eating behavior and consequently also with obesity and eating disorders. In fact, multiple functions integrated in the insular cortex correlate and interact with gustatory processes. It has been shown, that obese subjects show higher responses in the anterior insular cortex to food cues independent of the modality (taste, visual). Moreover, rtfMRI guided neurofeedback training of the insular cortex raises the possibility to modify eating behavior.

16The authors declare that the research was conducted in the absence of any commercial or financial relationships that could be construed as a potential conflict of interest.