Nitrogen Fixation in Cereals

1Cereals are grasses from the Poaceae family that were domesticated several thousand years ago in different geographical regions in order to take advantage of the edible components of their grain. Maize, rice, wheat, and sorghum are the most widely grown cereals consumed by humans and this review will focus on these crops. Nitrogen availability often limits cereal crop production. Adding nitrogen to crops has enhanced food production and has consequently increased the human population. In fact, the Haber-Bosch process that produces nitrogen fertilizers industrially has been called the detonator of human population growth. Increases in food production are urgently needed, yet fertilizers have already been overused, are expensive and polluting. Trends in crop management and genetics predict that crop production will not meet projected food needs in 2050. Higher agricultural production will require enormous additional inputs of nitrogen. Cereal production is highly dependent on chemical nitrogen fertilizers and the excessive use of these fertilizers is negatively impacting human and environmental health, including significant effects on the generation of greenhouse gasses and a reduced ozone layer. With the future menaces of a decline in petroleum reserves used in the Haber-Bosch process to produce inorganic fertilizers, besides the low efficiency with which plants use chemical nitrogen fertilizers, researchers are now seriously considering alternate sources of nitrogen for crop production.

2Biological nitrogen fixation (BNF) is a potentially attractive alternative source of nitrogen for cereal production. In fact, BNF by diazotrophic bacteria, which reduce dinitrogen to ammonium using nitrogenase enzyme systems, is the major contributor to the nitrogen economy of the biosphere, accounting for 30–50% of the total nitrogen in crop fields. Nitrogen fixation is an energetically expensive process. In theory, nitrogen fixation could fall under the black queen hypothesis. This hypothesis predicts that in communities of free-living microorganisms, there are only a few “helpers” that have costly functions, such as nitrogen fixation, that support the “beneficiaries” that are dependent on them for nitrogen supplies. Consequently, diazotrophs generally correspond to minor components of the ecosystems. Diazotrophs are found among alphaproteobacteria, gammaproteobacteria, Firmicutes, betaproteobacteria, and cyanobacteria but do not seem to be the most abundant (dominant) bacteria in plant rhizospheres, so there are possibilities for increasing nitrogen-fixation by favoring their populations. To enhance their competitiveness, plants may be selected or modified to increase exudation of nutrients that would favor the growth of diazotrophs (see below). Additionally, regular inoculation with diazotrophs as is common for legumes, could provide enough bacterial cells for the plant even if bacteria do not persist long in soils. Besides, low soil persistence may not be a disadvantage because it would allow subsequent introductions of more efficient symbionts as inoculants. Inoculant formulations and survival of inoculated bacteria are not within the scope of this review.

3Removing plant products from agricultural fields leads to nitrogen and other nutrient deficiencies. Therefore, achieving nitrogen fixation in cereals, like that which occurs in legumes, has been a long-cherished goal and has been considered as a holy “grail”. A huge interest in rice nitrogen fixation is reflected in books devoted to this subject. For many years, researchers have isolated, identified and tested a very large diversity of rhizospheric or endophytic isolates from plants. The practical aim has been to identify nitrogen-fixing bacteria that could be used as crop inoculants, but this has had limited practical success. The experience from efforts to increase nitrogen fixation in legumes showed contrasting results. Hypernodulating soybean plants resulted in diminished yields in some cases, but in others there was an increased productivity in subsequent crops.

4Diverse microbes are found associated with plants. There are comprehensive reviews on rhizospheric microbiota, diazotrophs and endophytes (residing inside plant tissues,;; ) of diverse plants including cereals, all focusing on bacteria. Rhizospheric and endophytic bacteria contribute to plant growth promotion by producing plant hormones, inhibiting pathogens or by enhancing mineral availability. In most cases, there is not sufficient evidence to consider that nitrogen fixation is a leading cause of plant growth promotion. For example, there are many reports on the growth-promoting effects of Azospirillum inoculation in maize, wheat, rice, and sorghum but these will not be reviewed here because the main beneficial effects are not primarily attributed to nitrogen fixation.

5In general, the contribution of nitrogen fixation in non-legumes is limited, however, Beijerinckia spp. inoculants promoted significant increases in nitrogen content in some maize hybrids. In contrast to what occurs in nodules, it is common that free-living nitrogen-fixing bacteria (diazotrophs) do not excrete nitrogen compounds to the host plant with ammonium instead being assimilated and used by bacteria for their own growth. The use of genetically modified bacteria was shown to improve plant growth through nitrogen fixation. For example, ammonium excreting Azospirillum exhibited enhanced nitrogen supply to wheat plants. Similar mutants of Azospirillum, Kosakonia, Pseudomonas, and Azotobacter proved capable of stimulating plant growth. We would recommend obtaining ammonium-excreting mutants of Paraburkholderia, Herbaspirillum, or Azoarcus as well, to test if they also improve plant growth through nitrogen fixation. Recently, engineered a root-colonizing non-diazotrophic endophyte, Pseudomonas protegens Pf-5, by transferring a stretch of DNA with 52 genes including the nif gene cluster from P. stutzeri. The modified P. protegens strain fixed nitrogen constitutively, even in the presence of combined nitrogen, and released significant quantities of ammonium into the surrounding medium. In greenhouse tests, demonstrated increased yields in maize and wheat inoculated with this engineered strain, and 15N isotope dilution analysis confirmed that this positive effect was clearly due to nitrogen fixation in roots.

6In this review we present additional information about associative nitrogen fixation as well as studies on the genetic modification of cereals directed toward obtaining nitrogen-fixing plants by the transfer of nitrogenase or nodulation genes into plants.

7Bacteria can get on to the plants either by root colonization from soil carryover, leaf litter, inoculation or via seed transmission. Seed endophytes can migrate from the seed and colonize the plant xylem but can also migrate from beneath the seed coats with the emerging root or even after the seed has germinated and colonize the rhizoplane and rhizosphere. found that only a few endophytes are able to spread from the root vascular tissue into the rhizosphere. The contribution of seed endophytes when colonizing the rhizosphere may be better observed in soils with low bacterial diversity.

8Seed-borne pathogens spread and perpetuate bacteria in new plant generations, similarly seeds may also carry beneficial bacteria that may be inherited to new generations. Non-pathogenic seed bacteria have been identified in Phaseolus vulgaris, maize, rice, wheat, alfalfa, and other plants. Previous analyses of seed endophytes have shown a large diversity of bacteria. Seed isolates from different plants are able to produce auxins, gibberellins, siderophores and ACC deaminase, solubilize phosphates, protect plants against pathogens and fix nitrogen.

9There are very few studies that analyze bacterial genes required for seed colonization. A P. putida mutant in a secretion system had reduced capacity to colonize maize seeds. Maize rhizospheric bacteria are more numerous and more diverse than seed endophytes, suggesting a bottleneck in the acquisition of bacteria by seeds.

10Seeds may also be colonized by bacteria present on the surfaces of stems, flowers, and fruits, as well as from pollen grains, which also harbor bacteria that can colonize the ovules after pollination. Rhizospheric bacteria seem to be mainly acquired from the soil or from leaf litter. Dependant on crop management history or soil pH. Root endophytic bacteria are acquired from the rhizosphere and a fraction of them can move through the xylem to colonize aerial parts, including seeds.

11To study novel sources of maize associated bacteria, we analyzed the contribution of irrigation and identified bacteria from the maize rhizoplane by sequence analysis of 16S rRNA gene amplicons from plants that were irrigated with water from two different Mexican rivers, Apatlaco and Tembembe. The maize rhizoplane irrigated with river water had river-borne bacteria, previously identified as Pseudomonas and there were common bacterial species in maize roots irrigated with water from both rivers, such as Acidovorax, Commamonas, and Herbaspirillum (Figure 1). From controls, irrigated with sterile water, only alphaproteobacteria from the Rhizobiales order were observed (Figure 1) and identified as Methylobacterium and Rhizobium. As these bacteria were recovered from plants that were maintained under sterile conditions in sterile vermiculite, irrigated with sterile water and derived from surface-disinfected seeds, they probably derived from kernel endophytes that found their way out of seeds to colonize the rhizosphere. However, seed-borne bacteria were outcompeted in roots by irrigation-borne bacteria, thus lowering the proportion of seed bacteria in the final composition of the plant microbiome from river water irrigated plants. Bacterial genera identified in the maize rhizoplane by a culture-dependent approach were included in this comparison (Figure 1). found many Firmicutes in the rhizoplane, similar to other reports. Previously we reported that each kernel had a different subset of endophytes, even when kernels belonged to the same cob. This indicated that not all seedlings in a germinating population would have the same bacteria, that would add biodiversity to plants and perhaps bring adaptive advantages.

12By using a culture-independent approach, a better representation of existing diazotrophs may be obtained while the analysis of nifH transcripts has provided results on active diazotrophs. This approach based on nif gene amplification and sequencing has been used to identify nitrogen-fixing bacteria associated with rice, sorghum, wheat and maize. There are no universal nif gene primers and diverse primers should be used to identify different genera or nitrogen-fixing bacterial families.

13In rice, a diversity of putative diazotrophs have been revealed by PCR amplification and sequencing of metagenomic DNA from roots. reported 23 nifH sequences from Oryza sativa cv. Nihonn in Japan which grouped with deltaproteobacteria (Desulfovibrio), gammaproteobacteria (Klebsiella-like, Azotobacter) and alphaproteobacteria (Thiobacillus-like) genes, the former two groups being the most abundant. Sixteen nifH sequences from rice analyzed by from DNA from root macerates clustered with genes from alphaproteobacteria (Bradyrhizobium, Azorhizobium, and Rhizobium) and betaproteobacteria (Azoarcus) as well with those from Firmicutes (related to Clostridium). Proteobacteria was also dominant among nifH sequences obtained from DNA extracted from rice in Thailand with betaproteobacteria being the most abundant (e.g., Herbaspirillum).

14Diazotrophs expressing nitrogenase reductase mRNA in association with rice have been identified. sequenced 117 nifH transcripts from O. sativa cv. Sprice and cv. Tetep grown in Japan and found that most sequences (>70%) belonged to a novel cluster related to Geobacter sulfurreducens (deltaproteobacteria), other sequences were affiliated with alphaproteobacteria (Bradyrhizobium and Methylocystis), betaproteobacteria (Azovibrio), gammaproteobacteria (Azotobacter), Firmicutes (related to Heliobacterium) and a polyphyletic group encompassing anaerobes. Azoarcus seemed as a dominant active nitrogen fixer in mixed rhizosphere/root samples from rice cultivated in a paddy soil in China while found an abundance of proteobacteria-related sequences from the alpha, beta and gamma subdivisions as well as fewer sequences from a polyphyletic anaerobe group when studying samples from the same site just one year later. In a proteomic approach, dinitrogen reductase proteins from Bradyrhizobium, Magnetospirillum, and Azospirillum have been detected in the rhizosphere of rice growing in Philippines.

15Among 245 nifH sequences obtained from soil DNA of sorghum (Sorghum bicolor) rhizospheres cultivated in Brazil, found mostly proteobacterial diazotrophs. Sequences were related to bacteria from the Rhizobiales, Burkholderiales, Sphingomonadales, Rhodospirillales, Enterobacteriales, and Bacillales. Diazotrophs with nifH sequences >98% identical to those of Bradyrhizobium and Rhizobium were common.

16The identity of diazotrophs inhabiting the rhizosphere and different tissues of maize (roots and stems) was determined by by sequencing nifH amplified from DNA extracts. They found that Proteobacterial sequences were the most prevalent in all analyzed tissues and also in the rhizosphere. Members of the alpha, beta, gamma, or delta subdivisions were present but the two former subdivisions were numerically dominant. The most abundant genera were Azospirillum, Bradyrhizobium, Herbaspirillum, Ideonella, Klebsiella, and Raoultella.

17Naturally-occurring diazotrophs were analyzed in all previous studies but some studies have evaluated the expression of nitrogenase genes of inoculated strains. reported the expression of nifH of Herbaspirillum sp. B501 in shoots of wild rice (O. officinalis) after inoculation of the bacteria to the seeds. Azospirillum brasilense FP2 applied to wheat (Triticum aestivum) was shown to express the nifHDK operon when colonizing roots. Another inoculant strain, Herbaspirillum seropedicae SmR1, was also able to express the same genes when attached to wheat roots.

18From these studies, it can be concluded that a wide diversity of bacteria possessing nifH genes are associated with cereals. It is worth noting that a significant proportion of the sequences obtained form clusters that are unrelated to known taxonomic groups. Functional molecular analyses in rice have shown that not all of these microorganisms are active at nitrogen fixation in association with the plant. The taxonomic composition of the active diazotrophs varies from plant to plant but Proteobacteria are always present and a polyphyletic group of anaerobes are very common. The presence of the latter group may be related to the nature of rice cultivation under water. Alphaproteobacteria from the Rhizobiales order, specifically of the Bradyrhizobium genus, have been found as active nitrogen fixers both by transcriptomic and proteomic approaches. Interestingly, in sugarcane, another member of the Poaceae family, bradyrhizobia also express nitrogen fixation genes in planta. Rhizobia in general have been used as biofertilizers in agriculture for more than a century and it will be worth exploring if bradyrhizobial inoculants can be developed for cereals.

19It is not uncommon to isolate human or plant pathogens from plants and in many cases they are efficient growth promoting bacteria. Their use in agriculture should not be encouraged. Among the nitrogen-fixing bacteria isolated from cereals there are human pathogens or potential human pathogens, such as Burkholderia cepacia and Klebsiella variicola. B. cepacia complex (BCC) includes seventeen species, some of them responsible for potentially lethal pulmonary infection in immuno-compromised or cystic fibrosis patients, and others are causative agents of infection in animals and plants. Members of this complex are generally good colonizers of plant rhizosphere and possess traits to improve plant growth. For a long time, B. vietnamensis, found in the rhizosphere and rhizoplane of maize, coffee, and sorghum plants was recognized as the only nitrogen-fixing species belonging to the BCC. However, new species of plant-associated Paraburkholderia diazotrophs have been reported, such as P. unamae, P. tropica, P. xenovorans from rhizospheric or endophytic association with maize, coffee, sorghum, or sugarcane. This group of bacteria has been found to comprise mainly environmental and plant-associated isolates. The presence of two transmissible virulence factor genes such as the cblA (encoding giant cable pili) and the epidemic strain marker regulator (esmR) identified among clinical isolates of opportunistic pathogens of B. cenocepacia and other species of the BCC have not been detected by PCR amplification and 32P hybridization in the environmental diazotrophic isolates of B. unamae and B. tropica. Thus, the lack of the aforementioned pathogenic traits supports the potential for using them as plant growth-promoting bacteria, since they were shown to have the ability to improve maize growth. Genomic analysis of the plant-associated Burkholderia and the pathogen B. cenocepacia for the occurrence of virulence determinants implicated in pathogenesis as well as the functional tests to determine pathogenicity showed that these two phylogenetic groups of Burkholderia belong to two distinct lineages. Mutualistic strains did not possess the virulence determinants tested and were susceptible to the vast majority of antibiotics. They did not kill Caenorhabditis elegans nor lyse of HeLa cells, unlike the pathogen B. thailandensis. Abundance of phylogenetic, biochemical, and molecular evidences for the occurrence of two different lineages within the genus Burkholderia finally led to a taxonomic revision with a split in the genus and allowed the environmental group to be renamed as Paraburkholderia, which nevertheless still includes a few human clinical isolates. Thus, some of the isolates that were formerly classified as Burkholderia species may still be considered suitable candidates as plant growth promoters.

20Klebsiella has been isolated from several distinct plants. However, its use in agriculture has been discouraged since some strains of Klebsiella were found to be pathogens or opportunistic pathogens of humans and animals. Comparative genomic analysis of K. variicola 342 (originally reported as K. pneumoniae) and K. pneumoniae MGH78578 showed that the latter cannot fix nitrogen, and there was a difference between these two species in the presence of genes essential for attachment, transport, and secretion. K. variicola 342 possesses genes that are involved in processing plant-derived cellulose and aromatic compounds but did not have a Type III secretion system that can be used to secrete effector proteins into the cytoplasm of eukaryotic cells, promoting their infection, nor genes encoding effector proteins. It was resistant to antibiotics. However, in the experiments conducted in mice to test pathogenicity, K. variicola 342 caused urinary tract infection like the clinical isolate C3091 but showed a significantly lower level of lung infection.

21On the other hand, other plant-associated bacteria such as Azospirillum, Herbaspirillum, Gluconacetobacter diazotrophicus and Azoarcus are considered safe and they are used as inoculants in agriculture. Azoarcus and Herbaspirillum have been shown to fix nitrogen in rice. The complete genome sequence of Herbaspirillum seropedicae SmR1, a spontaneous streptomycin resistant mutant, reveals it to be a metabolically versatile bacterium that contains genes coding for degradation of aromatic compounds. The limited number of genes related to mobile elements suggests a low rate of DNA transfer in this microorganism that is presumably due to adaptation to a stable microenvironment. H. seropedicae can synthesize plant-growth promoting substances such as auxins and gibberellins, and fixes nitrogen. It has a variety of protein secretion systems involved in plant bacterial recognition. Likewise, Azoarcus sp. BH72 genome contains few mobile elements in comparison to many soil bacteria or pathogens, which indicates that its genome has low plasticity. The strain appears to be “disarmed” compared to plant pathogens due to lack of known toxins as well as Types III and IV secretion systems. The lack of a N-acyl homoserine lactone-based communication system argues for a rather exclusive microhabitat and, the presence of genes coding for nitrogen fixation, chemotaxis, iron acquisition and biocontrol offer insight into genomic strategies for an endophytic life style and allow identification of various features that contribute to its interaction with plants.

22Rhizobia are also considered safe and have been used in agriculture as legume inoculants for more than one hundred years and their use in non-legumes is recommended as well. Bradyrhizobia have been found to be associated with wild rice in Africa, sweet potatoes in Japan and sugarcane in Brazil. Some Rhizobium genotypes are very efficient at colonizing maize roots. Rhizobia promote rice growth perhaps due to nitrogen fixation, and we suppose that bradyrhizobia may contribute fixed nitrogen to plants since some bradyrhizobial strains are capable of fixing nitrogen in the free-living state. A general brief overview of the rhizobial genetic repertoire to colonize non-legumes was published.

23Nitrogen fixation is highly variable depending on the associated diazotroph and the plant variety, but the host plant exerts a determinant effect by supplying the carbon and energy source for bacterial growth and nitrogen fixation. Aluminum or acid tolerant plants were found to sustain high levels of nitrogen fixation due to the exudation of dicarboxylic acids from their roots. The maize rhizosphere is a habitat favorable for diazotroph proliferation due to high quantities of exudates [accounting for 20–40% of all photosynthate], although unbalanced in C and N. Root exudates and plant secondary metabolites have a selective or inhibitory effect on bacteria. Sphingomonadales prefer root exudates from monocotyledonous plants rather than from other plants, but it may be premature to make general statements. Plant species, genotype, and age have effects on root microbiota.

24Phytoalexins and salicylic acid that mediate plant defense in legumes have inhibitory effects on plant-Rhizobium interactions, but less is known about the effects of defense alkaloids on diazotrophs in cereals. Maize bacillus and rhizobial endophytes were found to be resistant to MBOA, which is a toxic allelochemical in maize. Salicylic acid from plants restricts bacterial root colonization. Additionally, plants may interfere or stimulate quorum sensing signaling among bacteria, which may have significant effects by changing bacterial gene expression.

25Besides using associated bacteria to provide nitrogen to cereals other strategies involving the genetic modification of plants have been considered and are reviewed here. Two major approaches, transferring nitrogenase genes into crop plants and the development of the root nodular symbiosis in cereals, were envisioned as important avenues for achieving this target. Indeed, all these options have been considered and initial feasibility studies were conducted under the auspices of the International Rice Research Institute-coordinated multinational frontier project on “Assessing Opportunities for Nitrogen Fixation in Rice” during 1994–2001 (see ). However, major breakthroughs in the genomics of diazotrophs and the genetics of nitrogen fixation, as well as the processes involved in legume-rhizobia symbioses in recent years have opened up new avenues to tackle this problem much more systematically and have prompted the formulation of more workable schemes aimed at achieving this goal.

26For the goal of generating nitrogen-fixing cereal crops, several analogous projects funded by the Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation (BMGF, United States), the National Science Foundation (NSF, United States), the Biotechnology and Biological Sciences Research Council (BBSRC, United Kingdom) and the Indian Council of Agricultural Research (ICAR, India) have recently been initiated with differential emphasis on the choice of crop or experimental system. Among these, the first approach considers assembling of an active nitrogenase in plants through the incorporation and expression of bacterial genetic machinery to encode and support functional nitrogenase system. Nitrogen fixation is a highly energy demanding process, and so chloroplasts and mitochondria are envisaged as suitable sites for nitrogen fixation since they can meet the energy requirements for nitrogenase in plant cells. Nitrogenase is extremely sensitive to oxygen and irreversibly inactivated in air, and so the oxygen evolved by chloroplasts during photosynthesis may be detrimental to the maintenance of nitrogenase enzyme complex integrity. Thus, expressing functional nitrogenase in chloroplasts requires temporal (day/night) separation of photosynthesis and nitrogen fixation by confining nif gene expression only to dark periods (nights) or, alternatively, by spatially restricting nif gene expression to non-photosynthetic tissues such as the root system. As a proof of concept using yeast (a non-photosynthetic organism) as a model system, engineered nifH, nifM, nifS, and nifU from Azotobacter vinelandii into this eukaryotic cell and showed that active nitrogenase Fe protein can be produced if NifH polypeptide is targeted to the mitochondrial milieu jointly with the NifM maturase. They further demonstrated that for the generation of an active Fe protein, concomitant transfer of the NifH-specific Fe–S cofactor synthesizing protein components NifU and NifS into mitochondria is not essential, because NifH is able to acquire/incorporate endogenously generated mitochondrial Fe–S clusters. In a subsequent study, targeted a minimum set of nine A. vinelandii nif genes (nifH, nifD, nifK, nifU, nifS, nifM, nifB, nifE, and nifN) into mitochondria and demonstrated successful formation of NifDK tetramer, an essential first step in assembling a functional nitrogenase in a eukaryotic cell. nif gene transfer has also been attempted in plants. expressed NifH protein together with nifM in chloroplasts of tobacco plants, generating functional NifH, although with low activity. Recently, demonstrated the feasibility of expressing the complete range of biosynthetic and catalytic nitrogenase (Nif) proteins as mitochondrial targeting transit peptide-Nif fusions in tobacco leaves. Studies in both yeast and tobacco showed, however, that NifD polypeptide is prone to degradation in eukaryotic cells, thus warranting a need for optimizing its amino acid sequence to improve stability without compromising catalytic activity. We suggest that readers refer to the excellent recently published review articles for a comprehensive account of the strategy for nif gene transfer to eukaryotes.

27The second approach envisions the development of legume-like root-nodule symbioses (RNS) in cereal crop plants. This approach is based on contemporary knowledge on the development of the endosymbiotic associations of most land plants with endomycorrhizal fungi that form phosphate-acquiring arbuscular mycorrhizae (AM) in cereals and legumes, and with diverse diazotrophic rhizobia, to form nitrogen-fixing RNS in legumes. Genetic constituents that are critical for triggering initial processes for the development of AM symbiosis (AMS) are similar in both legumes and rice, and possibly in other cereals too. Moreover, in legumes, these same genetic components play a critical role in aiding initial stages of RNS development as well. Thus, genetic elements that participate in promoting both AMS and RNS development constitute the “common symbiosis pathway” (CSP; ). Current lines of research in cereals are making use of functionally conserved genetic constituents of the CSP as a foundation to extend genetic networks to assemble a complete signaling pathway to support legume-like RNS in cereal crops.

28An alternative option is to develop cereals that promote the growth of diazotrophs. Since the population density of endophytic bacteria in plant tissues is too low to support adequate nitrogen fixation, it is important to design systems that aid greater colonization of diazotrophic endophytes for improved nitrogen fixation in the crop plants. To achieve this, it is critical to improve the chances that the inoculated diazotroph will selectively colonize the crop plant. This is essential because newly introduced bacterial strains are usually out-competed by the native microbial communities in the rhizosphere of plants. This impediment could be surmounted by engineering plants to produce a specific metabolite and thus create a “biased rhizosphere” to favor the growth of an introduced diazotroph able to use the novel metabolite.

29Nitrogen fixation is a highly energy requiring process and the factors that limit symbiotic nitrogen fixation have been analyzed in only few legumes. For example, oxygen diffusion was found to limit carbon metabolism and nitrogen fixation in nodules. In legumes such as soybean, energy costs are significant for both N2 fixation and NO3 assimilation but are apparently somewhat greater for the former. estimated that in soybean, 5 CO2 are released per N2 fixed, while during nitrate assimilation approximately 5.7 CO2 are released per nitrogen assimilated in non-photosynthetic tissue, and 0–2.9 CO2 per nitrogen assimilated in photosynthetic tissue (see for detailed discussion). While there is no doubt that supplying ammonia (NH3) as a nitrogen source for plants reduces the energy requirement for nitrogen assimilation, the proper comparison that should most often be made (except for paddy rice) is between dinitrogen (N2) and nitrate as nitrogen sources, since nitrate is the most common alternative nitrogen source available in aerated soils. In plants that use nitrate as a source of nitrogen, nitrate first needs to be converted to ammonia to allow the synthesis of amino acids. Nitrate uptake and its conversion into ammonia is an energy requiring process. It has been estimated that carbon or energy costs for the conversion of NO3 to NH4+ is: ΔG = -605 kJ mol-1. Likewise, in the case of nitrogen-fixing legumes, N2 is first converted into NH4+, and then into amino acids. It is calculated that carbon or energy costs for the conversion of N2 to NH4+ is about -687 kJ mol-1. These theoretical carbon or energy costs for conversion of NO3 and N2 to NH4+ are quite similar.

30In legumes, there is no experimental evidence to support the contention that nitrogen fixation reduces yield. Fertilization in field conditions with various forms of combined nitrogen rarely produced any significant advantage to final yield of plants. Under greenhouse conditions as well, no significant yield differences were observed when the plants were grown on dinitrogen versus nitrate as a nitrogen source. This indicates that legumes using BNF rather than nitrate nitrogen suffer no obvious yield penalties. Urea and ammonium sulfate are normally used to fertilize rice. An important point to note here is that in spite of the greater energy requirement for nitrate assimilation (compared to ammonia assimilation), rice yields are better when grown on nitrate combined with ammonia as compared to ammonia alone. The fact that no yield penalty exists for rice grown on nitrate and ammonia rather than ammonia alone suggests that energy may not be limiting.

31The ability of plants to compensate for extra energy consumption cannot be ignored, as photosynthetic systems saturate at relatively low light intensity. Nevertheless, since source and sink metabolisms are tightly coupled, it is reasonable to assume that the extra energy consumption by roots would stimulate the production of biomass in shoots. It is well established that equilibrium between photosynthetic sugar synthesis in the chloroplast-containing leaf cells (source tissues) and sugar consumption by roots, fruits and grains (sink tissues) must be maintained for sustaining plant growth and survival. In plants under optimal light and at the normal carbon dioxide levels, sink limitation occurs when the rate of photosynthesis is limited by insufficient withdrawal of photosynthetic products generated in the green tissues through the Calvin–Benson cycle.

32It is intuitively envisaged that a nitrogen-fixing symbiosis in rice may be such a strong sink for photosynthate that yields would be impacted. Since rice is low in protein, a much lower rate of nitrogen fixation than in protein-rich legumes will be needed, with less demand for the plant’s photosynthates. In cereals, it has been estimated that as much as 29% of photosynthate is released as exudates by roots into the rhizosphere. From this, it may be inferred that cereals like rice have a capacity to sustain carbon/energy costs to support nitrogen fixation (through utilization of root exudates) without causing any strain on their productivity. Also, incidentally, in rice the actual grain yields are considerably lower than their maximum genetic potential. Therefore, in planta nitrogen-fixing attribute may not significantly impact the present yield levels.

33There has been a biotechnological interest to promote associative nitrogen fixation in non-legume crops that normally use large amounts of chemical fertilizers. Different nitrogen-fixing bacteria have been isolated from cereal roots by culture-dependent methods, and when used as plant inoculants they have varying degrees and strategies for plant growth promotion. Some past efforts to increase nitrogen fixation in cereals by promoting pseudonodules with phytohormones failed. Notably, recently obtained ammonium excreting mutants of some plant-associated diazotrophs were effective for promoting plant growth suggesting that they became capable of supplying nitrogen to their hosts. Even though achieving genetically-modified nitrogen-fixing cereal crops is a complex process, the approaches that are being pursued at present are creating exciting possibilities for generating such plants in the foreseeable future. If so, the global environmental benefits of a reduced chemical fertilizer usage will be large, and we suppose that detrimental ecological consequences of nitrogen fixing cereals will be minimal. Besides nitrogen, other agricultural inputs, such as phosphorus and water, may limit crop productivity. Mycorrhiza and plant cultivars with high phosphate use efficiency should be considered when developing nitrogen fixing cereals. However, we consider that not only the use of microbes and genetically modified plants will be required to achieve this goal, but a better crop management and efficient programs to control human population-growth are needed as well.

34MR wrote part of the “Introduction” and “Sources of Diazotrophic Bacteria,” contributed to the discussion and prepared the figure. EO-O wrote the part “Culture-Independent Identification of Diazotrophs in Cereals” and contributed to the discussion. AL-L wrote the part “Diazotrophs May Be Human Pathogens.” BR-H and MR contributed to the discussion and performed the laboratory experiments. JM-R contributed to the discussion, searched for references, and corrected the manuscript. PR wrote the parts “Prospects for Engineering Cereal Plants” and “Would Carbon Costs Incurred Due to in planta Nitrogen Fixation Reduce Crop Yields in Cereals?” EM-R wrote the parts “Abstract,” “Conclusion and Perspectives,” and “Plants as Determinants of Bacterial Interactions,” and also assembled the paper and coordinated the study.

35The authors declare that the research was conducted in the absence of any commercial or financial relationships that could be construed as a potential conflict of interest.