Not checkedNot checked for notices yet.
Reflexive anthropomorphism: Ontological ignorance, or ignorant ontology?
Nils Klowait
Социологический журнал · 2018
doi:10.19181/socjour.2018.24.1.5711 (opens in a new tab)
We email you when a new notice or a question about this paper appears.
Abstract
This article examines the methodological difficulties surrounding the topic of agency-ascription in human-computer interaction (HCI). The author evaluates a certain shift which occurred within this field, from analyzing computer-human interactions as model-like abstractions, which could be expressed in “program-like” scripts, to analyzing human-computer interactions as situated and locally unfolding events.This shift towards the situational, which has occurred through conversation-analytic interventions by authors such as L. Suchman and P. Luff, et al., raised the possibility of a conversation-analytic analysis of human-computer interactions. However, the use of the conceptual repertoire of conversation analysis poses a dilemma: the “talk is action” paradigm of CA would demand a certain conception ofinteraction, where all interactional participants would have some degree of agency, including the lifeless computer with its predetermined behavioral scripts.The paper proceeds to investigate one of the supposed solutions to the action vs. system dilemma: instead of stipulating that the computer possesses “true” agency, CA-minded researchers may instead opt for an “agency ascription” on behalf of the human co¬interactant. This anthropomorphism would supposedly permit an interactionist analysis without paying the price of accepting a non-human ontology.The paper looks into two ideal types of anthropomorphism which are present in interaction-focused HCI research: ontological and pragmatic anthropomorphism, analyzing their distinct features and how they relate to the possibility of analyzing HCI situationally. C. Nass’ “Media Equation” paradigm is considered as an example of ontological anthropomorphism, while S. Barley’s analysis of the introduction of CAT- scanners in two hospitals is taken as the foundation towards a pragmatic conception of agency-ascription, which is crucially dependent on the concepts of “seriousness” and “Uterahty” as they occur in situ.The paper concludes by cautioning against the use of anthropomorphism as a justification for interactionist HCI. It argues that the researcher cannot effectively probe for “serious” agency-ascription, as the degree of seriousness depends on the situation.
Abstract licence: CC BY
Reads
Read by people on this page
None yet.
Checked or read by AI through naulon
None yet.
A person counts once a day per paper. We keep no cookie and no address: a reader is a hash that changes every day. Any month under five reads shows no number.
Are you an author?
Is this your paper?
Claim it to add your note and be paid when agents cite it. Free.