Air Pollution and Inflammation (Interleukin-6, C-Reactive Protein, Fibrinogen) in Myocardial Infarction Survivors

1Ambient air pollution has been associated with cardiovascular mortality and hospital admissions for various cardiovascular diseases. Also, an elevated risk for acute myocardial infarction (MI) and cardio-respiratory symptoms has been reported in relation to air pollution. Some studies have suggested that patients with preexisting coronary heart disease (CHD) might be a particularly susceptible population.

2The exact mechanisms linking the inhalation of ambient air particles to an acute exacerbation of cardiovascular disease are not completely understood. Alveolar inflammation induced by particles may either directly or via oxidative stress lead to systemic inflammation with increased levels of blood coagulability, progression of atherosclerosis, and destabilization or even rupture of vulnerable plaques, resulting in acute ischemic events.

3So far, studies using repeated measures to assess the association between ambient air particles and inflammatory markers have had controversial results. In addition, they have been conducted only on a small scale, with samples sizes ranging from 9 to 112. In larger studies, however, associations have been based on single blood measurements, and the examined populations have encompassed healthy and diseased subjects, covering a variety of diseases. All these differences might explain the conflicting results.

4For interleukin 6 (IL-6), hypothesized to play a central role in the triggering of the inflammatory process, associations with high levels of particulate matter (PM) < 10 μm in aerodynamic diameter (PM10) have been shown, although a study in elderly subjects in the United Kingdom did not reveal significant associations with ambient PM10. The present study was designed to address the responses of IL-6, fibrinogen, and C-reactive protein (CRP) to elevated air pollution levels in a large cohort of MI survivors across Europe. We were particularly interested in MI survivors because they are especially prone to a progression of atherosclerosis and adverse cardiovascular events.

5A prospective longitudinal study of post-MI patients was performed in six European cities—Athens (Greece), Augsburg [Germany, KORA (Cooperative Health Research in the Augsburg Region)], Barcelona (Spain), Helsinki (Finland), Rome (Italy), and Stockholm (Sweden)—chosen to include a variety of geographic conditions and air pollution characteristics [see Appendix 1 for participants; see Supplemental Material (http://www.ehponline.org/docs/2007/10021/suppl.pdf) for data]. The study design is described in detail elsewhere. In brief, we recruited patients 35–80 years of age who had experienced an MI between 4 months and 6 years before the start of the study. Patients with MI or interventional procedures < 3 months before the beginning of the study or with chronic recurring inflammatory diseases such as Crohn’s disease were not included.

6Preferably, current nonsmokers were recruited. All partners approved the study protocol at their local human subjects committees, and written informed consent was obtained from all patients. All methods used in the study centers were conducted according to common standard operating procedures.

7Patients were invited to participate in six to eight clinical visits between May 2003 and July 2004. The visits were scheduled every 4–6 weeks on the same weekday and at the same time of the day to minimize the impact of weekly and circadian variation. At the first visit, a baseline questionnaire was administered regarding health status, medication intake, and smoking history. Blood pressure and body mass index (BMI) were measured and a blood serum sample was drawn to assess baseline serum lipids, glycosylized hemoglobin (HbA1c; an indicator of diabetic status) and N-terminal proB-type natriuretic peptide (NT-proBNP; an indicator for left ventricular dysfunction).

8At each clinical visit a 7-day recall on medication intake was obtained. Venous ethylene-diamine tetraacetic acid (EDTA)–plasma samples were collected for the determination of the inflammatory markers. Samples were cooled and stored at 4°C until further processing within a maximum of 4 hr. The EDTA-blood was centrifuged at 4°C in a precooled centrifuge for 20 min at 2,500 × g. Plasma aliquots were shipped on dry ice to the central laboratory in Ulm, Germany, and were stored at –80°C until analysis. Blood samples were analyzed by means of a commercial enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) for IL-6 (quantitative high sensitive IL-6 immunoassay; RD Systems GmbH, Wiesbaden, Germany) and immunonephelometry for fibrinogen and high-sensitivity CRP (Dade Behring Marburg GmbH, Marburg, Germany). Because CRP and fibrinogen concentrations were measured by a fully automated assay, only single measurements were available, except for results above and below the detection limit, which were double-checked. Within- and between-patient variability for a number of blood samples that were tested as quality assurance measures are described elsewhere.

9Air pollution data from fixed monitoring sites representing urban background concentrations were collected for each city according to standard procedures already employed in several European studies of air pollution. We obtained hourly means of particles [black smoke (BS), black carbon (BC), mass concentration of PM10, and mass concentration of particles < 2.5 μm in diameter (PM2.5)], gaseous air pollutants (carbon monoxide, sulfur dioxide, ozone, nitric oxide, nitrogen dioxide) and meteorologic variables (air temperature, relative humidity, barometric pressure, dew point temperature) through city-specific air monitoring networks and meteorologic services. If data were recorded locally at smaller units, at least 50% of the data for 1 hr needed to be present for the hourly value to be considered useable. For valid 8- or 24-hr mean values, at least 75% of the observations needed to be present. Particle number concentration (PNC) measurements as indicator for ultrafine particles were performed using condensation particle counters (CPC; 3022A; TSI, Shoreview, MN, USA) in all centers.

10Missing data on the aggregate level were replaced using a formula adapted from the APHEA (Air Pollution and Health—A European Approach) method [see Supplemental Material (http://www.ehponline.org/docs/2007/10021/suppl.pdf)]. We calculated apparent temperature by using the formula of and.

11We used moving averages of ambient concentrations of air pollutants and meteorogic variables to characterize the exposures by calculating the individual 24-hr average exposure for each person immediately preceding the clinical visit (lag 0) up to 4 days (lag 1–lag 4). In addition, we calculated the mean of lags 0–4 for the air pollution data and the mean of lags 0 and 1, the mean of lags 2 and 3, the mean of lags 0–3, and the mean of lags 0–4 for the meteorologic variables, if at least half of the relevant lags were available.

12Given previous findings, we hypothesized that particulate air pollution induces systemic inflammation. Specifically, we assumed that IL-6 would increase in association with increased levels of ambient particle concentrations of the preceding or same day, because immediate effects on IL-6 have been shown before, and the cytokine has a very short half life (2–6 hr).

13We also hypothesized that an acute-phase response involving de novo synthesis of proteins in the liver would require an induction time of 1–2 days. This would translate to an increase in fibrinogen concentrations with elevated particle concentrations of the previous 5 days [half-life 2–3 days (Thomas 1998)] and an increase in CRP in association with ambient particle concentrations 2–3 days before blood withdrawal [half-life 19 hr]. Similar results have been shown in previous studies.

14We analyzed data using mixed-effects models with random patient effects accounting for repeated measures. Because the half-lives of the markers were much shorter than the intervals between visits, we assumed a compound symmetry structure for the covariance matrix to model the correlation between repeated measures in each patient. Penalized splines (P-splines) in the additive mixed-model framework were used to allow for nonparametric exposure–response functions. IL-6 and CRP needed to be log-transformed to fulfill the model assumption of residual normality.

15City-specific confounder models without air pollutants were built for each blood marker separately. In addition to potential time-varying confounders, we included time-invariant patient characteristics associated with the mean levels of inflammatory markers to permit the assumption of a normally distributed random patient intercept.

16In a first step, time-invariant factors were selected for all cities combined. In the second step, for each city a more parsimonious model was selected out of the formerly chosen variables [see Supplemental Material, Table 1 (http://www.ehponline.org/docs/2007/10021/suppl.pdf)]. With this strategy, we adjusted for variables that influenced the mean levels of the respective blood markers in the single cities, such as age, sex, and BMI. These variables varied among the cities, possibly reflecting underlying differences in the populations across Europe as well as chance influences. To ensure sufficient adjustment for season and meteorology, long-term time trend and apparent temperature were forced into all models. Additionally, relative humidity, time of day, and day of the week were included if this adjustment improved the model fit. We considered lag 0, the mean of lags 0 and 1, the mean of lags 2 and 3, and the mean of lag 0–3 for the weather variables; for fibrinogen, we additionally assessed the mean of lags 0–4. P-splines were used to model continuous covariables and were compared with linear terms and polynomials of degrees 2 and 3. All decisions on goodness-of-fit were based on Akaike’s Information Criterion (AIC). Only after this adjustment did we examine mean changes of the inflammatory markers in association with air pollution. Single air pollutants were added and effects estimated linearly. After the city-specific data analyses, we assessed heterogeneity between centers. We combined city-specific effect estimates using meta-analysis methodology. Additionally, we checked whether active smoking, levels of NT-proBNP > 80 pg/mL, and HbA1c > 6.5%, respectively, modified the effects of air pollution on blood parameters.

17Data were analyzed using the statistical package SAS version 9.1 (SAS Institute Inc., Cary, NC, USA). Effect estimates are presented as percent change of geometric mean of the blood marker level (IL-6, CRP) and change of the arithmetic mean level (fibrinogen, percent of overall mean) together with 95% confidence intervals (CIs) based on an increase in air pollution concentrations from the first to the third quartile [interquartile range (IQR)].

18We performed sensitivity analyses to explore the robustness of the models by using a more parsimonious and an extended model. Also, indicator variables for season and for potential inflammation due to diseases or surgery shortly before the blood withdrawal were added to the model.

19Baseline characteristics of the study population are given in Table 1. In total, 1,003 MI survivors who had at least two valid repeated blood samples were taken into the analyses. These were 84% of the targeted 1,200 patients.

20Of 6,068 collected blood samples, 255 had to be excluded due to acute infections or surgical procedures 3 days before the clinic visit, because they could have severely altered concentrations of inflammatory markers. Overall, 5,813 plasma samples remained. For Athens, fibrinogen levels could not be assessed. IL-6, fibrinogen, and CRP showed a moderate correlation, with the Spearman correlation coefficient ranging from 0.41 to 0.51 for all single measurements and from 0.49 to 0.55 for the mean values per patient, with the data of all cities combined. The single cities showed similar correlation coefficients, Barcelona being the only exception, with a low correlation between fibrinogen and IL-6 (r = 0.22 and 0.25, respectively).

21The 24-hr average concentrations of the pollutants and meteorologic data are given in Table 2. PNC and PM2.5 were highest in the southern cities and lowest in Stockholm and Helsinki, whereas Augsburg showed intermediate levels (Figure 1).

22The pooled results for the regression of the three blood markers are summarized in Table 3. IL-6 showed borderline significant increases in association with PNC and NO2 with lag 0, one of the two a priori specified lags (Figure 2). Because IL-6 showed positive associations for lag 0, we analyzed the 24 hr of air pollution exposure before the blood withdrawal in more detail. PNC results indicate a time response with a slight increase 6–11 hr after an exposure, a clear increase with 12–17 hr after an exposure, and a drop back to the level of 0–5 hr thereafter (Figure 3). Results for 6–11 as well as 12–17 hr for all single cities show clear positive associations, except for Helsinki and Athens (6–11 hr) and Helsinki and Stockholm (12–17 hr).

23Fibrinogen was associated with an increase for the 5-day-average exposure of PM10. Other pollutants also indicate an increase for the 5-day-averages, but CIs were wide. In addition to the effect for the cumulative exposure, we found an increase for fibrinogen with lag 3 for PM2.5 and PM10 (Figure 3). For lag 3, results of the single cities show clear positive associations with PM2.5 for all cities except for Augsburg, where no association was seen. For PM10 and lag 3, results are heterogeneous. Except for Augsburg, all cities present positive associations, with Helsinki being the highest. Associations for PM2.5 and PM10 for the 5-day-average exposures were positive in all cities.

24Analyses of effect modification showed that for fibrinogen associations remained for the 5-day average exposure to PM10 for nonsmokers and patients with elevated NT-proBNP and HbA1c levels (Figure 4). Results for the single cities revealed clear positive associations for patients with elevated HbA1c levels in Helsinki and Barcelona, and small positive associations in Augsburg and Rome, whereas no association was found for Stockholm. Helsinki and Barcelona showed clear increases in fibrinogen levels with increased PM10 for patients with high NT-proBNP levels, whereas for the other cities only small increases were found. Active smokers were present only in Rome and Barcelona, and interactions with smoking thus were calculated only for these two cities. The combined results are driven mainly by the results from Barcelona, which indicate a strong positive association for nonsmokers. For CRP, no associations between ambient air pollution and serum concentrations were observed for either the a priori hypothesized time span or other lags.

25We performed sensitivity analyses for all blood markers, using selected air pollutants and the a priori specified lags (Table 4). For IL-6 and PNC, additional confounders in the model led to a clear positive result, whereas all other models, including the chosen model, were more conservative. For fibrinogen, overall results remained clearly positive and stable with PM10. With PNC a strong yet not significant association was found for the model without time-independent covariates. For CRP, results did not change in dependence on the model.

26We measured IL-6, fibrinogen, and CRP, three blood markers that indicate an inflammatory response, in MI survivors in six European cities. Pooled results show an increase in IL-6 when concentrations of PNC were elevated 12–17 hr before the clinical visit. Cumulative exposure to PM10 was associated with an increase in fibrinogen. No consistent associations could be detected for CRP.

27Air pollution seems to affect susceptible subgroups. We therefore examined MI survivors, a subgroup with an increased risk for readmission to the hospital, in six European cities, covering a wide range of gaseous and particulate air pollutants. There is a strong link between inflammation and CHD because factors involved in inflammation and infection seem to play a proatherogenic role, and inflammation has been identified as a potent risk factor for acute ischemic syndromes. Other risk factors such as cigarette smoking (: ), diabetes, or high BMI (: ) have also been found to be associated with low-grade systemic inflammation, providing a further link between inflammation and acute coronary events.

28Previous studies have shown an association between air pollution and blood markers of inflammation and coagulation. We examined IL-6 because of its role in the inflammatory cascade. IL-6 is produced by different cells in the body, including lymphocytes, monocytes, and endothelial cells. It is thought to play a major role in mediating stimuli from activated macrophages—for example, by smoking. IL-6 is the key cytokine that stimulates the synthesis of all major acute phase proteins, including CRP and fibrinogen. The latter factor induces an increase in blood viscosity and promotes thrombus formation.

29In a study in the United Kingdom, no significant associations were seen for a 3-day cumulative exposure to ambient PM10 and IL-6 levels. At high pollution levels, however, such as in road tunnels or during forest fires, positive associations have been observed. Our results indicate an increase in IL-6 within 12 hr after exposure, a requisite first step in the stimulation of the de novo synthesis of acute-phase proteins in the liver, triggered by ambient particles.

30Fibrinogen, an acute-phase protein, also plays a crucial role in the coagulation cascade. Studies regarding its association with air pollution are inconclusive. It has been shown to increase in association with high levels of ambient particles such as in an air pollution episode or in controlled human exposure studies. Also, positive associations, such as for PM10, have been reported at levels comparable to those measured in the present study. However, also null associations and even decreases in fibrinogen concentration in association with air pollutants have been reported. Our study indicates an increase in fibrinogen for lag 3 and the 5-day cumulative exposure for PM10.

31CRP, a well-known biomarker of systemic inflammation, has been one of the first acute-phase reactants to be examined in association with air pollution in several studies. Increased concentrations have been shown during an air pollution episode in Germany in healthy men, 45–64 years of age as well as for ambient PM10 levels currently present in Europe. Additionally, in a panel of CHD patients, an increase in CRP above the 90th percentile was found in association with ambient particles. Similar analyses did not reveal any effects in our data, which might be attributed to differences in the two panels. The AIRGENE panel consisted of both males and females and was on average slightly younger, but had more severe diseases than the subjects studied previously. On the other hand, the average CRP levels were lower in the AIRGENE panel.

32Overall, these studies suggest associations between inflammation and ambient air pollution concentrations, especially particles, although the effects between studies differ for individual data. To date, the reason for the heterogeneity is largely unknown. Different pollution mixtures, underlying medical conditions, treatments or diets with high anti-oxidant levels might be possible explanations.

33We observed immediate associations between PNC and IL-6 and cumulative effects between PM10 and fibrinogen. This is a surprising finding, which might be attributed to chance, because PM10 and PNC were not highly correlated in most cities. It is, however, also possible that their mode of action is different. Ultrafine particles or attached substances might translocate quickly into the bloodstream and lead to the observed changes in IL-6 without having a direct impact on the lung. PM10, on the other hand, might only exert an indirect systemic impact by provoking an inflammatory response in the lung that eventually causes oxidative stress, leading to the observed delayed increase in fibrinogen. However, these explanations are highly speculative. Further, PNC and PM10 differ not only by size but also by composition and redox activity, but the implications for the mechanisms are difficult to judge. When the city-specific results are examined, the immediate association between IL-6 and PNC was strongest in Augsburg, whereas the association between PM10 and fibrinogen was strongest in Helsinki for the 5-day-average exposure. Because these city-specific estimates were not heterogeneous, this may reflect the expected variation between independent studies. It also might point to differences in measurement error with respect to population average exposures characterized by central monitoring sites.

34One possible explanation for the lack of associations between air pollutants and CRP in our data could be the high prevalence of lipid-lowering drugs intake, particularly statins, which have been shown to reduce CRP through inhibition of its hepatic synthesis. Studies have shown that long-term therapy with a statin significantly lowers plasma levels of CRP. IL-6, which is produced upstream to the production of CRP in the liver, is not affected by this compound. Also, fibrinogen has been implicated to be reduced by fibrates but not statins. Because the majority of our patients reported an intake of statins, subgroup analyses did not seem reasonable.

35Increased concentrations of CRP are known to predict cardiovascular events in healthy subjects. Also, elevated levels of IL-6 have been found to be associated with total mortality and with risk of future fatal and nonfatal MI. Whether the short-term increases in IL-6 and fibrinogen observed in this study actually lead to an increased risk for an acute coronary syndrome, however, remains to be shown. A long-term follow-up study examining cardiovascular end points might help to answer the question whether subjects with elevated levels of inflammatory proteins in response to environmental stimuli have an increased risk of acute ischemic syndromes.

36The study is based on a common protocol and standard operating procedures applied in six European cities. Site visits were conducted to ensure uniform procedures. The analyses of the inflammatory markers were done in one central laboratory, and blinded duplicate samples were measured for quality assurance.

37Some of the measured biomarkers (e.g., CRP) are affected by health-related events such as acute infection or surgery. We therefore carefully excluded blood samples that might have been strongly influenced by other sources than air pollution before the statistical analyses. Moreover, thorough confounder adjustment was done to rule out the possibility that the detected associations resulted from meteorologic influences or seasonal differences, and repeated measures decreased the chance of confounding by time-independent variables, because each person served as his or her own control.

38Even though we included city-specific patient characteristics to account for differences in the panels, the city-specific estimates of the air pollution effects still varied. However, for those results indicating an association between air pollution and inflammation, these variations did not exceed the expected random variation. But it is also quite possible that the air pollution mixture, socioeconomic factors, or genetic background are responsible for these modifications. Indeed, we did observe effect modification for patients with elevated HbA1c and NT-proBNP.

39We observed only small changes in the acute-phase response that are not on the scale of a bacterial infection or surgery and presumably do not have any direct clinical relevance. Other factors, such as 10 pack-years of smoking, in comparison, led to increases of 2.7% (95% CI, 1.2–4.3) for IL-6, 1.2% (95% CI, 0.7–1.7) for fibrinogen, and 5.5% (95% CI, 3.0–8.0) for CRP in our data. A higher BMI of 5 kg/m2 was associated with significantly higher levels of IL-6 (16%), fibrinogen (3.8%), and CRP (38%). Smoking and overweight may be of concern in subpopulations, whereas air pollution usually affects whole populations and there is generally no voluntary component to the risk. Based on a publication by, we estimated that the increase in IL-6 we found in association with PNC might lead to a 0.7% (95% CI, –0.06 to 1.5) increased risk of CHD in elderly people without baseline cardiovascular risk. Despite the high prevalence of statin intake, our data still indicate an inflammatory response in association with air pollution. We therefore hypothesize that ambient air pollution might increase plaque vulnerability by these subclinical inflammatory responses.

40Our results indicate an immediate response of IL-6 to ambient air pollution, which might lead to the synthesis of acute-phase proteins, as indicated by increased fibrinogen levels. The lack of detectable associations for CRP may be attributed to a widespread intake of statins in our population, which might suggest a protective effect against environmental, proinflammatory stimuli—an intriguing phenomenon that deserves further study.