Biomarkers associated with delirium in critically ill patients and their relation with long-term subjective cognitive dysfunction; indications for different pathways governing delirium in inflamed and noninflamed patients

1Delirium is a serious and frequently occurring disorder in critically ill patients associated with both physical and cognitive impaired outcome. Because the pathogenesis of delirium is probably multifactorial, biomarker analysis may provide valuable information regarding the underlying mechanisms.

2Several previous investigations in non-ICU patients established an association between inflammation and delirium, as correlations between proinflammatory cytokine levels and delirium have been found. Furthermore, in elderly delirious patients with hip fractures, increased concentrations of IL-6, IL-8, and cortisol were correlated with elevated levels of the brain-specific protein (BSP) S100-β (a marker for astrocyte damage). Interestingly, sepsis is also associated with elevated levels of BSP. Furthermore, it has been hypothesized that serious illness such as sepsis, as well as the use of sedatives and analgesic, could result in apoptosis and long-term cognitive impairment. In mice, tumor-necrosis factor (TNF)-α is a mediator of apoptotic cellular death in the brain and may therefore be causally associated with the development of delirium in patients with severe inflammation.

3In the long term, delirium is associated with a more than 12-fold increased risk for developing dementia, resulting in permanent impairment of cognitive function that is associated with altered levels of amyloid-β. The association between biomarkers in delirious patients and long-term cognitive function is unknown.

4With regard to its multifactorial nature, it is likely that the underlying mechanisms of delirium may differ between inflamed and noninflamed patients. In the present study, we explored which biomarkers were associated with delirium in inflamed patients and which were associated with delirium in noninflamed patients, thereby using these biomarkers to explore whether different underlying mechanisms are involved. We included biomarkers that are directly linked to delirium, as determined in previous studies, and biomarkers that are linked with the onset of delirium. Apart from well-established pro- and antiinflammatory cytokines, we determined, for example, procalcitonin, macrophage migration inhibitory factor, and human neutrophil peptide-1, which play a role in inflammation, directly associated with delirium. Finally, we searched for correlations between mediators that were related to delirium and brain-specific proteins and cognitive functions 18 months after ICU discharge to establish whether the different pathways exert different long-term cognitive effects.

5A convenience sample was taken of all medical and surgical patients older than 18 years admitted to our Intensive Care Department (tertiary referral hospital in Nijmegen, the Netherlands) between February and July 2008. These patients were screened for delirium by using the confusion-assessment method-ICU (CAM-ICU). Patients were excluded when delirium screening during patients' complete ICU stay could not be performed (for example, because of persistent coma). Patients who were admitted to the ICU for trauma, postcardiac arrest, or neurologic reasons were also excluded. Finally, patients were excluded when they had a history of serious cognitive impairment, defined as reported in their medical history, or had from any form of dementia, delirium, or obvious signs of cognitive impairment reported by their relatives. If doubt existed concerning preexistent cognitive function, patients were not included in this study.

6In delirious patients, blood was drawn within 24 hours after the onset of delirium. For the nondelirious group, because no point in time exists to relate to, we draw blood after a similar ICU length of stay compared with that of the group of delirious patients. A total of 5 ml blood was drawn for all measurements.

7Delirium and nondelirium patients were furthermore divided into inflamed and noninflamed patients. This distinction was made because inflamed patients are suspected to have high levels of inflammatory mediators, and from a group of noninflamed patients, it is expected that they have low levels of inflammatory mediators. Inflamed was defined as a positive culture, regardless the origin from which specimens were taken, for which the patient was treated with antibiotics. Although systemic inflammatory response syndrome (SIRS) criteria lack specificity, the study was designed to differentiate between inflamed patients and noninflamed patients, and therefore, we used the presence of more than two SIRS criteria as a marker of inflammation. Absence of inflammation was defined as the absence of proven or suspected infection and the presence of no more than one SIRS criterion.

8The regional Medical Ethics Committee of Arnhem-Nijmegen approved the study and waived the need for informed consent because a single blood withdrawal is not considered a burden for the patient, and the results of this study did not influence the standard care for that patient. The study was registered in the Clinical Trial Register (NCT00604773).

9Demographic variables as well as illness-related characteristics were collected. The validated CAM-ICU method was used to detect whether patients were delirious. All patients were screened at least 3 times per day by using the CAM-ICU, with a high interrater reliability of 0.90 (95% CI, 0.82 to 0.98) Cohen kappa by well-trained ICU nurses. Patients were diagnosed with delirium when they had at least one positive CAM-ICU screening. Patients without any positive CAM-ICU screening during the complete ICU stay were classified as nondelirious. In case of doubt regarding the delirium diagnosis, patients were not included in this study.

10Blood for the determination of biomarkers was drawn between 6 and 10 a.m. and within 24 hours of the first positive CAM-ICU screening from an indwelling arterial line. Blood was centrifuged at 2,000 g for 15 minutes, and plasma was stored at -80°C until analysis. Proinflammatory cytokines (tumor necrosis factor (TNF)-α, interleukin (IL)-1β, IL-6, IL-8, IL-17, IL-18, and macrophage migration inhibitory factor (MIF), antiinflammatory cytokines (IL-1RA and IL-10), and the chemotactic cytokine MCP-1 were determined by using a simultaneous Luminex assay (Milliplex; Millipore, Billerica, MA, USA). Plasma defensin (human neutrophil peptide-1 (HNP-1)) was measured by using mouse anti-human HNP-1-3 monoclonal antibody (HyCult Biotechnology, Uden, The Netherlands), and the wells were then incubated with rabbit anti-human HNP-1-3 polyclonal antibody (Host Defence Research Centre, Toronto, ON, Canada), followed by incubation with peroxidase-conjugated goat-anti-rabbit IgG (Jackson ImmunoResearch). C-reactive protein (CRP) concentrations were measured by using immunologic detection (turbidimetric method, Aeroset; Abbott Laboratories, Abbott Park, IL, USA), and procalcitonin (PCT) levels were determined by using an immunometric assay with time-resolved amplified cryptate emission technology (PCT-sensitive Kryptor kit; Brahms, Middletown, VA, USA). The stress hormone cortisol was measured with luminometric immunoassay on a random-access analyzer (Architect i System, Abbott).

11The brain-specific proteins full-length amyloidβ1-42 and 1-40 (Aβ1-42 and Aβ1-40) and truncated Aβ-42 and -40 (AβN-42 and AβN-40) were determined in plasma by using a simultaneous Luminex assay (INNO-BIA plasma Aβ forms; Innogenetics, Ghent, Belgium), which has been shown to be a reliable assay with a low variability. Plasma levels of S100 calcium-binding protein-β (S100-β) and total human Tau were analyzed by using two commercially available enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) kits (Cosmo Bio Co., Ltd., Tokyo, Japan; and Cusabio Biotech Co. Ltd., Donghu; China, respectively). All biomarkers were determined according to the manufacturer's instructions.

12All included patients received the validated Dutch translation of the cognitive-failure questionnaire (CFQ) 18 months (median) after discharge from the ICU. The self reported CFQ measures four dimensions of cognition: memory, distractibility, social blunders, and names. Each question was scored on a 5-point Likert scale. The total score on the CFQ ranges from 0 to 100; a higher score indicates more-severe cognitive dysfunctioning. The subjective CFQ shows good correlation with more-quantitative mental health tests. An extensive description concerning the use of the CFQ in critically ill patients was recently published.

13Differences in baseline characteristics between delirious and nondelirious patients were tested by using χ2 tests and the Mann-Whitney U or Student t tests, depending on its measure and distribution. Biomarkers and CFQ data were successfully log transformed to obtain normally distributed data. To determine the association between biomarkers and delirium in the inflamed and the noninflamed group of patients, univariate logistic regression analysis was performed. To examine the associations between the biomarkers and delirium, a multivariate logistic regression analysis method backward conditional was performed, including biomarkers with the 10 best-associated biomarkers in the univariate analysis. Correlations between biomarkers and CFQ outcomes, measured 18 months after ICU discharge, were determined by using Pearson's correlation coefficients.

14Because of the exploratory nature of this study, no correction for multiple testing was performed to increase sensitivity. Statistical significance was defined as a P value < 0.05.

15All data were analyzed by using SPSS version 16.01 (SPSS, Chicago, IL, USA).

16In total, 105 patients were screened for this study, of which five patients were excluded for reasons of doubt concerning the delirium diagnosis or history of cognitive dysfunction of the patients. In three patients, it was not possible to retrieve information about the relatives, and in two patients, some doubt existed concerning the delirium diagnosis (in both cases, the CAM-ICU was negative). In total, 100 patients were included for this study, of whom 50 patients were delirious during the ICU stay, and 50 patients were not delirious during the ICU stay. No statistically significant differences in demographic variables and several clinical covariates related to delirium were observed between groups of 50 delirious and 50 nondelirious patients (Table 1). No difference was noted between both groups regarding the moment of blood withdrawal counted from ICU admission (Table 1). Several pro- and antiinflammatory cytokines, PCT as marker of inflammation, stress response hormone cortisol, as well as several brain-specific proteins differed significantly between delirious and nondelirious patients (Table 2). Of note, all measured levels of biomarkers were well above the lower detection limit. Differences in biomarkers between inflamed and noninflamed delirious patients are illustrated in Additional file 1.

17This group consisted of 26 delirium and 20 nondelirium ICU patients. Several pro- as well as antiinflammatory cytokines, PCT, and cortisol were significantly higher in the delirium group compared with the nondelirium group (Table 3). Levels of brain-specific proteins were comparable between the groups, except for a borderline-significant elevated level of S100-β in the delirium group (P = 0.07). In univariate logistic regression analysis, IL-8, MCP-1, PCT, cortisol, and S100-β were significantly (P <0.05) associated with delirium. Extended with the biomarkers TNF-α, IL-6, IL-18, IL-1ra, and IL-10, the 10 best biomarkers associated with delirium (all P < 0.10) were then entered into a multivariate logistic regression analysis. This multivariate analysis demonstrated a significant association between the proinflammatory cytokine IL-8 (odds ratio, 9.0; 95% CI, 1.8 to 44.0) with the presence of delirium in inflamed patients.

18This group of patients consisted of 24 delirium and 30 nondelirium ICU patients. The proinflammatory cytokines IL-6 and IL8 as well as the antiinflammatory cytokines IL-1ra and IL-10 and level of PCT were significantly higher in delirious patients compared with the nondelirious patients. Furthermore, several amyloid-β forms differed significantly, and Tau levels differed borderline significantly between the two groups (Table 3).

19Biomarkers that were significantly associated with delirium were IL-8, IL-1ra, IL-10, ratio Aβ1-42/40, and ratio AβN-42/40. Furthermore IL-6, PCT, cortisol, ratio Tau/Aβ1-42, Aβ1-40, and AβN-40 were in total the 10 best, with delirium-associated biomarkers (all P < 0.10) in univariate logistic regression analysis. Multivariate logistic regression analyses with these biomarkers showed a significant association of ratio Aβ-42/40 (OR, 0.03; 95% CI, 0.002 to 0.50) and the antiinflammatory cytokine IL-10 (OR, 2.6; 95% CI, 1.1 to 5.9) with the presence of delirium in noninflamed patients.

20At a median of 18 months after ICU discharge, 10 of the 100 ICU patients had died. Except for a significantly lower level of IL-1β in the survivors group, no other differences were found between the survivors and nonsurvivors (data not shown).

21In total, 52 (58%) patients of the 90 survivors returned the CFQ; 23 (44%) of these were delirious during their ICU stay. No important differences were noted between nonresponders and responders concerning age (69 ± 8 versus 73 ± 6 years; P = 0.12), APACHE-II (16 ± 3 versus 15 ± 4; P = 0.31), gender (male, 46%, versus 54%; P = 0.45), delirium (46% versus 44%; P = 0.60), and inflamed (55% versus 40%; P = 0.29).

22The Aβ1-40 and the Aβ1-42/40 ratio correlated with the domain distractibility (r = 0.30; P = 0.03; and r = -0.28; P = 0.04, respectively). The AβN-42/40 ratio correlated with the domain memory (r = -0.30; P = 0.03). AβN-40 correlated with the domain social blunders (r = 0.31; P = 0.03). AβN-40 and the AβN-42/40 ratio correlated significantly with the total CFQ score (r = 0.30; P = 0.04; and r = -0.34; P = 0.02, respectively).

23We found no correlation between S100-β, total human Tau, cortisol, or any of the other measured inflammatory mediators, CFQ, age, APACHE-II score, and mean blood pressure. In addition, we found no correlations between CFQ and age, APACHE-II score, and length of stay in the ICU.

24The patient numbers per subgroup were too low and therefore did not allow us to perform correlation analyses between biomarkers and the different subgroups because of lack of statistical power.

25This study shows that differences exist in various inflammatory mediators associated with delirium between inflamed and noninflamed patients. After multivariate regression analysis, IL-8 was associated with delirium in inflamed patients, whereas in noninflamed patients, IL-10 and Aβ-42/40 were associated with delirium. These differences between inflamed and noninflamed ICU patients in delirium-associated biomarkers suggest that the underlying mechanism governing the development of delirium in inflamed patients differs from that in noninflamed patients. Furthermore, we demonstrated that, in contrast to inflammatory mediators, different forms of amyloidβ significantly correlate with long-term subjective cognitive problems in ICU patients, illustrating that the underlying mechanism of delirium is relevant for its long-term cognitive consequences.

26This is the first study investigating plasma amyloidβ (Aβ) levels and human Tau in critically ill patients in relation to the presence of delirium. In view of the reported increased incidence of dementia after ICU/hospital admission, our findings could provide a possible mechanistic link, because noninflamed delirium is associated with Aβ, but this must be confirmed in a longitudinal study focusing on these biomarkers combined with more-extensive cognitive testing. Furthermore, Aβ is associated with sustained long-term subjective cognitive dysfunction in ICU patients. Studies comparing plasma levels of Aβ between Alzheimer (AD) and non-Alzheimer dementia patients and controls have yielded conflicting results with respect to levels of different forms of Aβ. Increased levels of Aβ1-42 as well as increased levels of Aβ1-40 were found in dementia patients. In addition, increased levels of the Tau/Aβ1-42 ratio have been found in cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) of patients with cerebral amyloid deposition, but this has not yet been investigated in plasma. In the present study, the difference in levels of total Tau and the Tau/Aβ1-42 ratio between noninflamed delirious patients and noninflamed nondelirious patients approached statistical significance. It is known that plasma levels of Aβ are age dependent; however, this could not have confounded our results because no differences in age existed between delirious and nondelirious patients in our study. Additionally, the patients investigated in this study were not recognized with a history of cognitive impairment by patients' medical history and information from their relatives, which could explain differential Aβ levels. The lower Aβ1-42/40 ratio, probably due to an increase of Aβ1-40 at a constant Aβ1-42 level, in combination with a significant correlation with long-term cognitive failure on several domains of the CFQ are in accordance with findings that elevated levels of Aβ1-40 increase the risk of developing dementia. Importantly, this finding of early lower Aβ1-42/40 ratio and ratio Aβ1-40/N-40 in delirious patients without signs of serious previous cognitive impairment makes it tempting to speculate that this represents the first sign of an imbalance in the Aβ metabolism. To our knowledge, these early findings of imbalance in Aβ metabolism have not been reported. Our findings might therefore shed new light on the important question whether delirium plays a causative role in the development of dementia in later life, or if delirium is the first sign of dementia. Because deposition of Aβ in the brain is generally considered to be a long-term process, and samples in our study were drawn shortly after the onset of delirium, it is more plausible that delirium may be the first sign of an early dementia process. However, a cause-effect relation cannot be determined in a cross-sectional observational study like ours. This hypothesis of early imbalance in Aβ metabolism in delirious patients must be confirmed in future studies.

27Previously, it was demonstrated that delirium is associated with elevated levels of IL-6, IL-8, and S100-β in non-ICU patients and with IL-6 and S100-β in ICU patients with sepsis. IL-8 levels were not measured in these sepsis patients. We showed, by using a multivariate logistic regression analysis, that levels of IL-8 in inflamed patients were associated with delirium, but IL-6 was not. A possible reason for this discrepancy might be that we determined biomarkers directly after the first positive delirium screening, whereas it has been shown that the highest levels of IL-6 occur in the later phase of delirium.

28Several limitations of our study should be addressed. First, we used the CAM-ICU to diagnose delirium in ICU patients instead of the gold standard: the DSM-IV criteria. It is recognized that it is not feasible to use this gold standard in ICU patients, and therefore the CAM-ICU is an accepted alternative to diagnose delirium in the ICU. The CAM-ICU has the highest sensitivity and specificity rate of all delirium-assessment tools and is well implemented in the daily practice of our nurses with a high interrater reliability. In addition, to strengthen the delirium diagnosis, all medical and nurse files of the patients were analyzed, and patients were not included when in doubt of the delirium diagnosis.

29Second, we did not use a validated cognitive-assessment tool such as the informant questionnaire on cognitive decline short form (IQCODE-sf), which is a surrogate evaluation to determine whether the patient had serious cognitive impairment before ICU admission. Instead of this, we used information from medical records and the next of kin of the patients to identify whether the patient had a history of cognitive impairment. In case of any reference to or sign of cognitive impairment, patients were not included in our study. Furthermore, as a measure of patients' cognitive function 18 months after ICU discharge, we used the validated CFQ, which is a self-evaluated questionnaire to detect cognitive-based failures and not dementia and is also not a specific psychometric test, which may result in more-objective data. Although this can be considered a limitation of our study, our findings are the results of patient's own perception of cognitive functioning and are therefore informative and relevant.

30Third, in this study, we measured biomarkers only at one point in time. In a longitudinal biomarker study, a difference in cytokine levels before and during delirium was found. In the absence of biomarker data in critically ill patients with delirium, we chose to perform an exploratory study to investigate which biomarkers were most strongly associated with delirium immediately after the onset of delirium. This was an exploratory hypothesis-generating study, of which the results may facilitate hypotheses for future research.

31Fourth, potential covariates must be considered as a potential limitation of the study, in contrast to a randomized trial in which possible covariates are likely to be equally divided between the groups. Although baseline patient characteristics were comparable between the delirium and nondelirium groups, unbalanced influence of covariates cannot be ruled out in such an observational study as we performed.

32Last, we measured levels of brain biomarkers in peripheral blood and not directly in material derived from the brain or cerebrospinal fluid. It is recognized that levels of Aβ1-42 in cerebrospinal fluid of AD patients are decreased, but studies on plasma Aβ forms have yielded ambiguous results. A large prospective study showed that increased plasma levels of Aβ1-40 increased the risk for dementia, especially when the concentration of Aβ1-42 was increased. This results in a decrease of ratio Aβ1-42/40. A combination of different brain-specific proteins, such as a combination of Aβ with Tau concentrations in CSF, improves discrimination between AD patients and controls. Although it has been recommended to determine these biomarkers in CSF rather than in plasma, our results are in accordance with these findings. Interestingly, levels of Tau, ratio Tau/Aβ1-42, and Aβ1-40 were increased in inflamed delirious and nondelirious patients and in delirious noninflamed patients, but appear to be lower in nondelirious noninflamed patients. It can be argued that a blood-barrier change during systemic inflammation may play a role. This may also suggest that determining neuronal biomarkers in plasma can be used instead of only CSF samples. Obviously, CSF samples are not routinely obtained in our ICU patients. To our knowledge, a study investigating the correlation between CSF and plasma levels of Aβ has yet to be performed.

33In inflamed patients, the proinflammatory cytokine IL-8 was independently associated with delirium, whereas in noninflamed patients, the ratio Aβ1-42/40 and IL-10 were independently associated with delirium, as determined by multivariate regression analyses. This suggests that the underlying mechanism governing the development of delirium in inflamed patients differs from that in noninflamed patients. These findings illustrate the relevance of distinguishing between inflamed and noninflamed when investigating biomarkers in delirious patients. Finally, elevated levels of amyloid-β correlated with long-term cognitive impairment. These findings are in line with the notion that delirium in noninflamed ICU patients may represent the first sign of a (subclinical) dementia process. Future research into the relation of delirium, amyloid forms, and long-term cognitive function should include more-extensive tests of cognitive function.

34• Two different pathways exist in delirious inflamed and noninflamed ICU patients

35• Delirium in inflamed patients is independently associated with the proinflammatory cytokine IL-8, and in noninflamed patients, delirium is independently associated with the antiinflammatory cytokine IL-10 and the ratio amyloidβ-42/40.

36• These increased amyloid-β concentrations, but not increased cytokine concentrations correlate with long-term cognitive failure.

37Aβ1-42/40: amyloidβ1-42 and 1-40; AβN-42/40: amyloidβ truncated-42 and 1-40; AD: Alzheimer disease; APACHE-II: acute physiology and chronic health evaluation-II; BSP: brain-specific proteins; CAM-ICU: confusion-assessment method, intensive care unit; CFQ: cognitive failure questionnaire; CRP: C-reactive protein; CSF: cerebrospinal fluid; DSM-IV: Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders-IV; HNP: human neutrophil protein-1; IQCODE-sf: Informant Questionnaire on Cognitive Decline Short Form; IL: interleukin; MCP: monocytes chemotactic protein 1; MIF: macrophage migration inhibitory factor; RASS: Richmond Agitation Sedation Score; S100-β: S100 calcium-binding protein-β; SIRS: systemic inflammatory response syndrome.

38The authors declare that they have no competing interests.

39MvdB carried out the study, collected all data and blood, performed the statistical analysis, and drafted the manuscript. MK measured plasma biomarkers and drafted the manuscript. PP and LS supervised the conduct of the study and writing of the article. KQ measured plasma biomarkers and corrected the manuscript. JvdH and TvA co-supervised and corrected the manuscript.

40All authors read and approved the final manuscript.