Skip to content
naulon
Not checkedNot checked for notices yet.

Does mentoring new peer reviewers improve review quality? A randomized trial

Houry Debra, Green Steven, Callaham Michael

BMC Medical Education · 2012

doi:10.1186/1472-6920-12-83 (opens in a new tab)

We email you when a new notice or a question about this paper appears.

Abstract

<p>Abstract</p> <p>Background</p> <p>Prior efforts to train medical journal peer reviewers have not improved subsequent review quality, although such interventions were general and brief. We hypothesized that a manuscript-specific and more extended intervention pairing new reviewers with high-quality senior reviewers as mentors would improve subsequent review quality.</p> <p>Methods</p> <p>Over a four-year period we randomly assigned all new reviewers for <it>Annals of Emergency Medicine</it> to receive our standard written informational materials alone, or these materials plus a new mentoring intervention. For this program we paired new reviewers with a high-quality senior reviewer for each of their first three manuscript reviews, and asked mentees to discuss their review with their mentor by email or phone. We then compared the quality of subsequent reviews between the control and intervention groups, using linear mixed effects models of the slopes of review quality scores over time.</p> <p>Results</p> <p>We studied 490 manuscript reviews, with similar baseline characteristics between the 24 mentees who completed the trial and the 22 control reviewers. Mean quality scores for the first 3 reviews on our 1 to 5 point scale were similar between control and mentee groups (3.4 versus 3.5), as were slopes of change of review scores (-0.229 versus -0.549) and all other secondary measures of reviewer performance.</p> <p>Conclusions</p> <p>A structured training intervention of pairing newly recruited medical journal peer reviewers with senior reviewer mentors did not improve the quality of their subsequent reviews.</p>

Abstract licence: CC BY-NC-ND

Cited by papers we hold1

Reads

Read by people on this page

None yet.

Checked or read by AI through naulon

None yet.

A person counts once a day per paper. We keep no cookie and no address: a reader is a hash that changes every day. Any month under five reads shows no number.

Are you an author?

Is this your paper?

Claim it to add your note and be paid when agents cite it. Free.