Not checkedNot checked for notices yet.
Medical Residency Interviews: Time for a Change?
Chad M. Teven, MD, William J. Casey, III, MD, Alanna M. Rebecca, MD, MBA
Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery, Global Open · 2020
doi:10.1097/gox.0000000000003037 (opens in a new tab)
We email you when a new notice or a question about this paper appears.
Abstract
Coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) has had profound effects on medical education within the United States. Some affected practices (eg, exclusion of senior medical students from clinical rotations) are likely to recover as rates of COVID-19 infection decline and hospitals return to normal procedures. Timing of recovery of other medical education practices is less clear. For example, the future of medical residency interviews remains uncertain. As of May 14, 2020, the American Association of Medical Colleges recommends that all interviews with potential students and trainees be conducted virtually.1 This relates in part to uncertainty regarding the safety of air travel and large gatherings. Before determining the appropriate resumption of on-site interview practices, a more fundamental question must be considered first: Whether to return to on-site interviews at all. On-site interviews have long been considered integral to the graduate medical education application process. Reported advantages of on-site interviews are numerous (Table 1).2 On-site interviews facilitate assessment of candidates regarding noncognitive factors (eg, communication skills) and negative characteristics (ie, red flags) by programs. Applicants describe face-to-face interaction with program members, particularly residents and the program director, as very beneficial. Additionally, on-site interviews are shown to strongly influence rank list construction by both program directors and candidates.2 Table 1. - Advantages and Disadvantages of On-site Residency Interviews2,4 Applicants Advantages Face-to-face interaction with program members (eg, residents, program director) Assessment of program and social fit Assessment of program intangibles (eg, morale, “red flags”) Correlates with rank list construction Disadvantages Significant cost (financial and opportunity) Potential for inequitable experiences among applicants (eg, interviewer bias) Financial, scheduling, and cultural factors may influence outcome Reported benefits unsubstantiated by available literature Significant absence from medical school Residency programs Advantages Face-to-face interaction with candidates Assessment of noncognitive factors and negative characteristics Correlates with rank list construction Disadvantages Significant cost (financial and opportunity) Does not adequately predict residency training outcomes Reported benefits unsubstantiated by available literature In contrast, opponents to traditional interviewing have leveled many criticisms (Table 1). First, on-site interviews result in substantial financial and opportunity costs to applicants and programs. During the 2014–2015 application cycle, the average cost to each applicant participating in on-site interviews was $3422.71.3 Next, low interrater reliability, interviewer bias, and absence of standardized approaches may result in dissimilar and inequitable experiences among applicants.2 Across distinct disciplines, on-site interviews have been shown to handicap candidates who are financially disadvantaged, have scheduling conflicts, or are culturally dissimilar to interviewers.4 However, despite these shortfalls, a viable alternative to on-site interviews has remained elusive. Before the onset of the current pandemic, authors recently began suggesting implementation of virtual interviews in an effort to mitigate drawbacks associated with on-site interviews.3 However, few formal studies of virtual interviews exist.3,5 Theoretically, virtual interviews allow for an equitable application process while concurrently reducing costs and optimizing flexibility for candidates and programs. Although both virtual and traditional approaches have attendant strengths and weaknesses (Table 2),3 we believe that the disadvantages of on-site interviewing outweigh its benefits to a greater extent than for virtual interviewing. Table 2. - Advantages and Disadvantages of Virtual Residency Interviews3,5 Applicants Advantages Increased scheduling flexibility Reduced cost Significantly less time away from work Potentially reduced biases Disadvantages Precludes face-to-face interaction and assessment of noncognitive factors Most applicants consider less effective than traditional Residency programs Advantages Increased scheduling flexibility Reduced cost Disadvantages Precludes face-to-face interaction and assessment of noncognitive factors Most program directors consider less effective than traditional Moving forward, a comparative analysis of virtual and traditional approaches is necessary to optimize the interview process in a data-driven fashion. In the upcoming application season, it is likely that residency programs will hold virtual interviews due to lingering effects of COVID-19. Should this occur, medical schools, residency programs, and additional stakeholders will have an opportunity to formally and on a widescale basis examine the benefits, limitations, and utility of virtual compared with on-site interviewing, as well as overall impact on the application process. Such an opportunity must not be squandered. Indeed, we believe that virtual interviews are not simply an alternate to traditional interviews, but may prove superior. DISCLOSURES The authors have no financial interest to declare in relation to the content of this article.
Abstract licence: CC BY-NC-ND
References4
4 more references, whose wording the paper’s licence keeps private.
Reads
Read by people on this page
None yet.
Checked or read by AI through naulon
None yet.
A person counts once a day per paper. We keep no cookie and no address: a reader is a hash that changes every day. Any month under five reads shows no number.
Are you an author?
Is this your paper?
Claim it to add your note and be paid when agents cite it. Free.