The Most Disruptive Publications in Plastic Surgery
Daniel Neubauer, MD, Jessica D. Blum, MS, Stephanie G. Labou, BS and 5 more
Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery, Global Open · 2021
doi:10.1097/01.gox.0000799776.65987.a8 (opens in a new tab)
We email you when a new notice or a question about this paper appears.
Abstract
BACKGROUND: The impact of academic publications is often characterized by the total number of future citations of the work. However, this metric does not adequately characterize the true impact in terms of changing practices or paradigms. A newly created metric called the “disruption score” (DS) has been developed and validated in non-surgical publications.1 This study aimed to evaluate the DS metric to identify the most disruptive publications in the Plastic Surgery literature. The DS, a ratio of two numbers, varies between −1 and +1. The numerator is the number of articles that cited the focal article without also citing any of its references minus the number of artciles that cited the focal article and at least one of its references. The denominator is the total number of times the focal article was cited plus the number of papers that cited at least one of the references of the focal paper, but not the focal paper itself. Scores closer to −1 are developing articles that summarize the known literature, whereas articles closer to +1 are disruptive—they result in a paradigm shift in the field of study. METHODS: A search was performed for all articles from 1954 to 2014 in the following journals: Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery, Aesthetic Surgery Journal, Journal of Plastic, Reconstructive, and Aesthetic Surgery, Annals of Plastic Surgery, Aesthetic Plastic Surgery, Clinics in Plastic Surgery, and Plastic Surgery. The DS was calculated for each journal article. The top 100 articles ranked by DS were examined and any editorials/viewpoints, publications with less than 26 citations, or less than three references were excluded due to their subjective nature and smaller academic contribution. The remaining 64 publications were analyzed for topic, study type, and citation count. Sub-analysis of the 36 excluded articles was performed. RESULTS: A total of 32,622 articles were found in the seven journals. The DS Score ranged from 0.385 to 0.923. The mean score of the top 64 articles was 0.539 with an average citation count of 195 and 9 references. Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery had the most disruptive articles with 50, Journal of Plastic, Reconstructive, and Aesthetic Surgery had the next most with 12, and Annals of Plastic Surgery had 2. There were no randomized control trials with a majority of the studies being technical descriptions or case series. CONCLUSIONS: There are many ways to measure academic success, but there are fewer ways to measure the impact of academic contributions on a field. The DS is a novel measurement that can demonstrate when an article results in a paradigm shift as opposed to just total citation count. When applied to the body of plastic surgery literature, the DS demonstrates that technical innovation and creativity is the most academically impactful. Future evaluations of academic success should include the Disruption Score to measure the quality of academic contributions. REFERENCE: 1. Wu L, Wang D, Evans JA. Large teams develop and small teams disrupt science and technology. Nature 2019;566(7744):378–382. doi:10.1038/s41586-019-0941-9
Abstract licence: CC BY-NC-ND
Reads
Read by people on this page
None yet.
Checked or read by AI through naulon
None yet.
A person counts once a day per paper. We keep no cookie and no address: a reader is a hash that changes every day. Any month under five reads shows no number.
Are you an author?
Is this your paper?
Claim it to add your note and be paid when agents cite it. Free.