Skip to content
naulon
Not checkedNot checked for notices yet.

Patient Perspectives on Breast Implant Illness: A Mixed-methods Analysis of Public Comments from Regulations.gov

Leen El Eter, BS, Kimberly Khoo, BSA, Elisabeth Abeles, BA and 12 more

Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery, Global Open · 2021

doi:10.1097/01.gox.0000799256.24052.d3 (opens in a new tab)

We email you when a new notice or a question about this paper appears.

Abstract

BACKGROUND: Rising reports on Breast Implant Illness (BII) have brought breast implant safety into question. Because BII may be considered controversial, BII may not be fully considered for patients experiencing symptoms, highlighting the necessity of patient advocacy, improved disease investigation, and breast implant evaluation. On 24 Oct 2019, the FDA posted draft guidance on Regulations.gov about breast implant labeling recommendations to improve patient communication, for which it invited public comments. This study aimed to characterize public comments made regarding the FDA’s Black Box Warning to better understand patient emotions and thoughts surrounding implants, BII, and communication. METHODS: In August 2020, we extracted all comments on breast implant labeling from the 24OCT2019 Regulations.gov docket. We coded comments using a qualitative analysis tool (Dedoose) into five emotions described in previous studies (anger, disgust, fear, joy, sadness, and trust) and themes themes evaluating the adequacy of patient education (black box warning, physician-provided information/patient education, content/language of the forms/documents provided, and informed consent). Two independent reviewers coded comments and a third reviewer reconciled conflicts. We conducted a statistical analysis to quantify emotion, theme frequencies, and inter-coder reliability. Queries were performed to generate word clouds related to “symptoms,” “negative attributes,” and “positive attributes.” RESULTS: Of the 1321 extracted comments, four were non-English and 559 were duplicates. Of the duplicates, 449 were a verbatim repetition of the following: “I am writing to express my concern about the safety of breast implants and to urge the FDA to strengthen the drafted guidance entitled Breast ImplantsCertain Labeling Recommendations to Improve Patient Communication.” We coded the remaining 758 comments. The most frequently coded emotion was anger (present in 61.6% of comments); 595 (78.5%) comments were coded with at least one negative emotion. The most frequently coded theme was “inadequacy of informed consent” (49.1%); there were no resultant comments coding for “adequacy” in any of the themes. For any comment coded with ≥1 emotion, the most frequent theme to co-occur was “Inadequacy of information/patient education provided by the physician,” followed by “Inadequacy of informed consent.” The word query revealed that for “symptoms” and “negative attributes” word clouds, the most frequently coded terms were “autoimmune” (n = 165) and “warnings” (n = 547), respectively. For terms associated with positive attributes, the word “thank” was mentioned 95 times in the context of responders thanking the FDA for receiving patient feedback. Inter-coder reliability analysis showed heterogeneous agreement; however, the theme “Inadequacy of black box warning” returned the highest level of agreement (Kappa: 0.322–0.795, P < 0.05). CONCLUSIONS: Our mixed-methods analysis revealed that patients concerned about Breast Implant Illness frequently experienced anger and disappointment with quality of informed consent and absence of device Black Box Warnings. While the subjective nature of coding contributed to differences in theme recognition, strong agreement regarding “Inadequacy of black box warning” demonstrates the clarity with which this was expressed by patients. While public responders expressed negative emotions, their appreciation of the FDA in hearing these comments demonstrates the importance of considering public feedback to address health concerns and generate improved patient education materials and communication regarding surgical devices.

Abstract licence: CC BY-NC-ND

Reads

Read by people on this page

None yet.

Checked or read by AI through naulon

None yet.

A person counts once a day per paper. We keep no cookie and no address: a reader is a hash that changes every day. Any month under five reads shows no number.

Are you an author?

Is this your paper?

Claim it to add your note and be paid when agents cite it. Free.